Q is the daughter of R, who is the mother of S. T is the father of Q. How is T related to S?
- (a)Son
- (b)Husband
- (c)Brother
- (d)Father
Answer
Why
Correct — D.
Rule: place everyone on one family tree, then read T's line to S.
R is the mother of Q and of S, so Q and S are siblings.
T is Q's father, so T is R's husband.
T is therefore S's father → option (d).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)Son — Son reverses the generations. T is Q's parent and Q is S's sibling, so T sits above S, not below.
- (b)Husband — Husband is T's relation to R, the mother. The question asks about S, R's child.
- (c)Brother — Brother would put T in S's generation. As Q's father, T is one generation above both Q and S.
Concept
Chain statements are easiest on a small tree: parents on the top row, children below. Here R goes on top with Q and S beneath her, and T joins R on the top row as Q's father.
Once Q and S hang from the same couple, T's relation to S is the same as his relation to Q: father. S's gender is never given, and it does not matter, because father is the same word for a son or a daughter.
The stem never says T is R's husband. That step holds if Q and S share both parents, which is the reading the key takes.
Key facts
- R is the mother of both Q and S, so Q and S are siblings.
- T, as Q's father, is R's husband and S's father.
- Father is the answer whether S is a son or a daughter.
Study next
Common traps
- Answering Husband, which is T's relation to R, not to S
- Stalling because S's gender is not given, when the answer does not need it
21 Sep 2025, 16:00, Reasoning Q.12 asks the same step directly: A is the father of B, B is the brother of C, so A is C's father (keyed b).
18 Sep 2025, 12:30, Reasoning Q.22 runs it with a daughter: P, Q and R are siblings and S is P's father, so R is S's daughter (keyed a).
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.