Change the following from active to passive: The authorities are to close the road.
- (a)The road to be closed by the authorities.
- (b)The road is to be closed by the authorities.
- (c)The road has to be closed by the authorities.
- (d)The road will be closed by the authorities.
Answer
Why
Correct — B. The active verb is are to close: be + to-infinitive, which expresses a plan or an official arrangement.
In the passive, the object, the road, becomes the subject, and the infinitive turns passive: to close → to be closed.
The be-verb stays but agrees with the new singular subject: are → is.
Result: The road is to be closed by the authorities → option (b).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)The road to be closed by the authorities. — No finite verb. The road to be closed by the authorities is a phrase, not a sentence: without is, nothing carries the tense.
- (c)The road has to be closed by the authorities. — has to swaps the construction: it expresses necessity, where are to expresses an arrangement. A voice change keeps the original auxiliary and changes only its form.
- (d)The road will be closed by the authorities. — will be closed is a plain future passive. It drops the be-to form and with it the sense of a fixed arrangement; the passive of are to close keeps is to.
Concept
Be + to-infinitive — The President is to address the nation tonight, You are to report at nine — expresses an arrangement, a plan or an instruction.
To make it passive, keep the be-verb and turn the infinitive passive: to + be + past participle. The authorities are to close the road → The road is to be closed by the authorities.
The be-verb then agrees with the new subject. A plural doer, the authorities, gives way to a singular subject, the road, so are becomes is.
Options (c) and (d) are grammatical passive sentences. They fail because each changes the verb the active sentence used, not because of their grammar.
Key facts
- Be + to-infinitive expresses an arrangement or instruction: The President is to address the nation tonight.
- The passive of be to + verb is be to + be + past participle: is to be closed.
- A voice change keeps the auxiliary and adjusts only its number to the new subject.
Study next
Common traps
- Keeping are because the active sentence had it, though the new subject, the road, is singular
- Picking will be closed or has to be closed because they sound natural, without checking that the verb itself has changed
24 Sep 2024, 12:30, English Q.12 runs the same pattern with have to: We have to say little in this matter becomes Little has to be said in this matter. The semi-modal stays, and have becomes has for the new singular subject.
11 Sep 2024, 16:00, English Q.5 does it with a modal: He must deliver pizza → Pizza must be delivered by him.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.