Read the following statement carefully and identify the conclusion that follows. Statement: The economy grew by 8% this year, the highest in a decade. Conclusions: I. Economic reforms have been successful. II. Growth in previous years was below 8%.
- (a)Only Conclusion I follows
- (b)Only Conclusion II follows
- (c)Both I and II follow
- (d)Neither I nor II follows
Answer
Why
Correct — B.
Rule: a conclusion follows only if the statement alone guarantees it.
II follows: 8% is the highest in a decade, so the other years of that decade grew by less than 8%.
I does not: the statement gives the figure, not its cause. Nothing in it mentions reforms.
Only Conclusion II follows → option (b).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)Only Conclusion I follows — Conclusion I credits reforms, but the statement names no cause for the growth. Linking the two is an addition, not an inference.
- (c)Both I and II follow — Both needs I as well, and I adds a cause the statement never gives. II alone rests on the words the highest in a decade.
- (d)Neither I nor II follows — Neither throws out II, yet the highest in a decade means exactly that the other years of the decade were below 8%.
Concept
A conclusion must follow from the statement as written. A superlative carries a comparison inside it: the highest in a decade means this year beat every other year in that span.
A cause is different. Saying growth was high does not say why, and many causes would fit the same sentence. A conclusion that names one of them goes beyond the statement.
II holds for the years inside the decade. The statement is silent on anything earlier, so 'previous years' has to be read as the rest of that decade.
Key facts
- The highest in a decade means every other year of that decade was lower.
- A statement of a result does not state its cause.
- A conclusion that adds a cause or a prediction goes beyond the statement.
Study next
Common traps
- Accepting I because reforms are a familiar explanation for growth
- Rejecting II because the statement does not list the earlier years' figures
15 Sep 2025, 12:30, Reasoning Q.11 uses the same instruction and options on a library open 9 AM to 5 PM, and keys 'not accessible before 9 AM' as the conclusion that follows (b).
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.