View answer copy →Answered a very similar question
Their question: “MGNREGA fund corruption by senior officials; whistleblowing dilemma”
The PYQ puts the officer in charge of a Panchayat where MGNREGA funds were siphoned via fake muster rolls and fictitious payments, the identical scheme-corruption scenario Nisar tackles, closing on 'sunlight is the best disinfectant'.
Key learnings from their answer
- ›His closing lines were matched to the specific question, not generic: the Sanskrit shloka 'Yatra Naryastu Pujyate Ramante Tatra Devta' to close the temple-excluding-women case study (Q8/CS2), and 'Sunlight is the best disinfectant' to close the MGNREGA whistleblowing case (CS6) -> end every answer with a quote or maxim that is topically wired to that exact dilemma, so the conclusion reinforces the argument rather than ornamenting it.
- ›Across all six case studies he ran a single rigorous scaffold: issues -> options -> a merit/demerit table -> chosen action -> justification, repeatedly landing on a consultative 'middle path' (stakeholder committee, internal escalation before going public) -> a fixed, table-driven case-study template lets you show you weighed alternatives instead of jumping to a verdict, and the examiner can see the reasoning at a glance.
Quotes used: “'Sunlight is the best disinfectant' — Case Study 6 (author not written; Brandeis)” “'Silence of good men in the face of injustice is a bigger crime' — Case Study 6 (author not written)”