What type of number is the result of multiplying a Rational Number with an Irrational Number?
- (a)Always Rational
- (b)Always Irrational
- (c)Always Integer
- (d)Sometimes Rational, Sometimes Irrational
Answer
Why
Correct — D. The answer turns on zero, which is a rational number.
Non-zero rational × irrational: if r ≠ 0 and r × s = q were rational, then s = q ÷ r would be rational too. So 2 × √2 = 2√2 is irrational.
Zero × irrational: 0 × √2 = 0, which is rational.
Both outcomes occur, so the product is sometimes rational, sometimes irrational → option (d)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)Always Rational — 2 × √2 = 2√2 is irrational, so the product is not always rational. A rational result needs the rational factor to be 0.
- (b)Always Irrational — Fails for zero: 0 × √2 = 0, and 0 is rational. 'Always irrational' holds only when the rational factor is non-zero.
- (c)Always Integer — 1⁄2 × √2 = √2⁄2 is not an integer, and neither is 1 × √2 = √2.
Concept
A rational number can be written as p⁄q with integers p and q, q ≠ 0. Zero is 0⁄1, so it is rational. An irrational number, such as √2 or π, cannot be written that way.
For a non-zero rational r and an irrational s, r × s is always irrational, because dividing by r would make s rational. Zero is the one exception: 0 × s = 0 for every s.
The familiar rule 'rational × irrational = irrational' is true only for a non-zero rational. The stem says 'a Rational Number' without excluding zero, so zero counts, and the key takes 'sometimes'.
Key facts
- Zero is a rational number (0 = 0⁄1).
- A non-zero rational times an irrational is always irrational.
- An irrational times an irrational can be rational (√2 × √2 = 2) or irrational (√2 × √3 = √6).
- A rational plus an irrational is always irrational.
Study next
Common traps
- Forgetting that 0 is rational and marking 'Always Irrational'.
- Assuming an irrational times an irrational stays irrational: √2 × √2 = 2.
The options are four claims, three of them 'always'. A single counter-example rejects each 'always', so test 0, 1⁄2 and 2 against √2 before choosing.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.