A bucket has 60 litres of a solution with sugar and water in the ratio 5:1. If 12 litres of the solution are replaced with water, what is the new ratio?
- (a)2:1
- (b)2:3
- (c)3:1
- (d)3:2
Answer
Why
Correct — A.
Split 60 L in 5 : 1: sugar 50 L, water 10 L
12 L of solution carries the same 5 : 1 split
Sugar removed: 10 L, water removed: 2 L
Left: sugar 40 L, water 8 L
Add 12 L water: 8 + 12 = 20 L of water
New ratio: 40 : 20 = 2 : 1 → option (a)
Why the others are wrong
- (b)2:3 — 2 : 3 puts water ahead of sugar. After the swap there are 20 L of water against 40 L of sugar, so sugar still leads.
- (c)3:1 — 3 : 1 with 40 L of sugar needs about 13.3 L of water. The bucket holds the 8 L left over plus the 12 L added, which is 20 L.
- (d)3:2 — 3 : 2 with 40 L of sugar needs about 26.7 L of water — more than the 20 L actually there after the 12 L top-up.
Concept
When you draw off part of a well-mixed solution, each ingredient leaves in the ratio it sits in the bucket. 12 L of a 5 : 1 solution carries out 10 L of sugar and 2 L of water.
Then only the added liquid changes: water goes up by 12 L, sugar does not. The total returns to 60 L (40 + 20), a quick check on the working.
Shortcut for one replacement with pure water: sugar keeps the fraction (60 − 12)⁄60 = 4⁄5 of its amount. Sugar = 50 × 4⁄5 = 40 L, and water is the rest of the 60 L.
Key facts
- Removing part of a mixture takes out each ingredient in the mixture's own ratio
- Replacing R litres of a V-litre mixture with water leaves the other ingredient at (V − R)⁄V of its amount
- After n such replacements it is at ((V − R)⁄V)ⁿ of its amount
Study next
Common traps
- Subtracting the whole 12 L from the sugar alone, as if only sugar left the bucket
- Forgetting the water that left: keeping water at 10 L and adding 12 gives 22 L instead of 20 L
13 Sep 2025, 12:30, Quant Q.14 removes 15 L of a 3 : 2 milk-water mixture the same way (9 L milk, 6 L water) before adding 10 L of milk, keyed 23 : 12.
15 Sep 2025, 09:00, Quant Q.13 repeats a replacement twice: 100 × (9⁄10)² = 81 L of syrup left, keyed 81 : 19.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.