Change the following from active to passive: Someone must have tampered with the encryption keys.
- (a)The encryption keys must have been tampered with.
- (b)The encryption keys must have tampered by someone.
- (c)The encryption keys must be tampered with by someone.
- (d)The encryption keys must had been tampered with.
Answer
Why
Correct — A. The active verb is must have tampered with: a modal perfect (must have + past participle) on the prepositional verb tamper with.
The passive of a modal perfect is must have been + past participle:
must have tampered with → must have been tampered with
The keys become the subject. The indefinite agent someone is dropped, and with stays after the verb → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)The encryption keys must have tampered by someone. — must have tampered has no been, so it is still active in form and says the keys did the tampering. It also drops the with that tamper needs.
- (c)The encryption keys must be tampered with by someone. — must be tampered with loses have, turning a deduction about the past into a present deduction or a requirement. A voice change keeps the time reference.
- (d)The encryption keys must had been tampered with. — must had been breaks the modal rule: a modal is followed by the base form, so must have, never must had.
Concept
A voice change keeps the tense and the modal; what moves is the subject and the object. For a modal perfect the passive frame is modal + have been + past participle: must have been done, could have been seen.
A prepositional verb (tamper with, look into, laugh at) keeps its preposition in the passive, so the preposition ends up after the participle: the keys must have been tampered with.
The keyed sentence has no by-phrase. That is normal when the active subject is someone, people or they: by someone adds nothing, so it is usually left out.
Key facts
- Modal perfect passive: modal + have been + past participle.
- A modal takes the base form: must have, never must had.
- A prepositional verb keeps its preposition in the passive: tampered with, looked into.
- An indefinite agent such as someone or people is usually omitted in the passive.
Study next
Common traps
- Dropping the preposition. The keys must have been tampered is incomplete, because tamper needs with.
- Keeping have but forgetting been, which leaves the sentence active in form.
A modal is carried into the passive at 11 Sep 2024, 16:00, English Q.5 (He must deliver pizza, keyed Pizza must be delivered by him) and at 15 Sep 2025, 16:00, English Q.12 (may confer, keyed may be conferred).
The passive of tamper with, preposition kept, appears inside 18 Sep 2025, 12:30, English Q.23: had the evidence not been tampered with.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.