A sentence is provided in direct speech. From the four given options, choose the one that most accurately conveys the sentence in its corresponding indirect speech. She said, “I can solve this problem.”
- (a)She said that she will solve that problem.
- (b)She said that she could solve this problem.
- (c)She said that she could solve that problem.
- (d)She said she can solve the problem.
Answer
Why
Correct — C. The reporting verb said is past, so the reported words shift back and away:
can → could (modal backshift)
this → that (nearness words move away)
I → she (the pronoun follows the speaker)
She said that she could solve that problem → option (c)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)She said that she will solve that problem. — Wrong modal. "Can" expresses ability and backshifts to could. "Will" is a different modal, about the future, and even it would become would after a past reporting verb.
- (b)She said that she could solve this problem. — Half converted. "Could" is right, but this has to become that: the report is made later, away from the problem the speaker was pointing at.
- (d)She said she can solve the problem. — Leaves can unshifted. After the past verb said, the standard conversion turns can into could, and this into that, not "the". Dropping "that" after said is not the fault: it is optional.
Concept
Reported speech after a past reporting verb moves the speaker's words one step back in time and one step away in place.
Modals: can → could, will → would, shall → would or should, may → might.
Place and time: this → that, here → there, now → then, today → that day.
Pronouns: change to fit the reporter, so I → she.
A correct option makes every required change.
The exam convention. In everyday English the backshift can be skipped when the statement is still true ("She said she can swim"). This item expects the full shift, and the key makes it.
Key facts
- After a past reporting verb: can → could, will → would, may → might.
- Nearness words move away: this → that, these → those, here → there, now → then.
- The conjunction "that" after said is optional, so leaving it out is not an error.
Study next
Common traps
- Changing the modal but leaving "this" unchanged.
- Rejecting an option only because it drops "that" after said.
24 Sep 2025, 16:00, English Q.22 tests the same modal: "I can play the piano" is keyed "She said she could play the piano", with no "that".
13 Sep 2025, 12:30, English Q.22 turns on the demonstrative: "I like this pen" becomes "Ravi said he liked that pen".
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.