Pointing to a photograph, a man says, “She is the daughter of the only son of my father's wife”. Who is the woman to the man?
- (a)Sister
- (b)Cousin
- (c)Niece
- (d)Daughter
Answer
Why
Correct — D.
Rule: resolve the phrase from the innermost relation outward.
My father's wife = my mother
The only son of my mother = the man himself
The daughter of the man = his daughter → option (d).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)Sister — Sister skips a link. "The daughter of my father's wife" would be his sister, but this phrase first passes through "the only son", the man himself.
- (b)Cousin — A cousin is the child of a parent's sibling. The phrase names no uncle or aunt: it runs mother → her only son → his daughter.
- (c)Niece — A niece is a brother's or sister's daughter. The only son of the man's mother is the man himself, so the woman is his own child.
Concept
Photograph relation items pack a whole chain into one phrase. Resolve it from the innermost relation outward, replacing each piece with a person.
"My father's wife" is the speaker's mother. The only son of the speaker's mother must be the speaker himself, because he is a man and her son.
The phrase collapses to "the daughter of me", so the woman is his daughter.
Key facts
- "My father's wife" is read as "my mother".
- A male speaker who is his mother's only son has no brother.
- "Only son" rules out a brother, not a sister.
Study next
Common traps
- Stopping at "my father's wife's daughter" and answering Sister
- Treating "the only son" as a brother when the speaker is male
Near-identical wording is keyed at 12 Sep 2025, 16:00, Reasoning Q.20: "the daughter of my mother's only son" is the man's daughter. When a girl speaks, as at 13 Sep 2025, 12:30, Reasoning Q.23, her mother's only son is her brother, and his son is her nephew.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.