Two containers, A and B, contain mixtures of alcohol and water. Container A has alcohol and water in the ratio 4:1, while Container B has them in the ratio 5:2. If 10 liters are drawn from Container A and 14 liters from Container B, and the contents are mixed in a third container, what is the ratio of alcohol to water in the new mixture?
- (a)3:1
- (b)7:2
- (c)9:4
- (d)11:3
Answer
Why
Correct — A. Split each drawn quantity in its own container's ratio, then add like with like.
From A (4 : 1, so 5 parts): alcohol = 10 × 4⁄5 = 8 L, water = 10 × 1⁄5 = 2 L
From B (5 : 2, so 7 parts): alcohol = 14 × 5⁄7 = 10 L, water = 14 × 2⁄7 = 4 L
Total alcohol: 8 + 10 = 18 L
Total water: 2 + 4 = 6 L
Ratio 18 : 6 = 3 : 1 → option (a)
Why the others are wrong
- (b)7:2 — 7 : 2 makes water 2⁄9 of the mix, about 5.3 L of the 24 L. The two draws carry exactly 2 + 4 = 6 L of water, a quarter of the mix.
- (c)9:4 — 9 : 4 makes water 4⁄13 of the mix, about 7.4 L of the 24 L. The two draws carry only 2 L + 4 L = 6 L of water.
- (d)11:3 — 11 : 3 makes water 3⁄14 of the mix, about 5.1 L of the 24 L. The draws actually carry 6 L of water against 18 L of alcohol.
Concept
A quantity drawn from a well-mixed container carries that container's ratio. So 10 L of a 4 : 1 mixture is 8 L alcohol and 2 L water.
Ratios cannot be added directly. Convert each draw into litres of each liquid, add alcohol to alcohol and water to water, and only then form the new ratio.
Why adding the ratio terms seems to work here. 4 + 5 : 1 + 2 = 9 : 3 = 3 : 1 matches, but because each draw is exactly 2 × its ratio sum (10 = 2 × 5, 14 = 2 × 7).
Draw 7 L from B instead and the litres give 13 : 4, while the shortcut still says 3 : 1.
Key facts
- A quantity drawn from a mixture in ratio a : b contains a⁄(a + b) of the first liquid.
- Combine mixtures by adding actual quantities of each component, not by adding ratios.
- Check a ratio against the total: 3 : 1 of 24 L is 18 L and 6 L, the amounts found.
Study next
Common traps
- Adding the ratio terms (4 + 5 : 1 + 2) as a method — it matches here by coincidence and fails when the draws are not the same multiple of their ratio sums.
- Splitting 10 L by 4 instead of by 4 + 1 = 5 parts, which gives 2.5 L a part instead of 2 L.
The drawn portion carrying its mixture's ratio also decides 13 Sep 2025, 12:30, Quant Q.14: 15 L removed from a 3 : 2 milk-water mix takes 9 L milk and 6 L water, and adding 10 L milk leaves 46 : 24 = 23 : 12.
10 Sep 2024, 16:00, Quant Q.11 compares two mixtures by each one's milk fraction: 10⁄16 and 8⁄12 give 15 : 16.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.