The distance between the centers of two circles is d. The lengths of their direct and transverse common tangents are L and M, respectively. If L² + M² = 200 and the sum of the squares of their radii is 100, what is the value of d?
- (a)10
- (b)10√2
- (c)5√2
- (d)20
Answer
Why
Correct — B. Write both tangent formulas and add them, so the individual radii drop out.
Direct: L² = d² − (r₁ − r₂)²
Transverse: M² = d² − (r₁ + r₂)²
Add: L² + M² = 2d² − [(r₁ − r₂)² + (r₁ + r₂)²]
Expand the bracket: (r₁ − r₂)² + (r₁ + r₂)² = 2(r₁² + r₂²)
Substitute: 200 = 2d² − 2 × 100, so 2d² = 400
Solve: d² = 200, d = 10√2 → option (b)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)10 — 10 is what L² + M² = 2d² gives if the radius terms are dropped. With them back in, d = 10 makes L² + M² = 200 − 200 = 0, not 200.
- (c)5√2 — 5√2 makes d² = 50, so L² + M² = 100 − 200 = −100. A sum of two squares cannot be negative.
- (d)20 — 20 is √400, the root of 2d² before halving. d = 20 makes L² + M² = 800 − 200 = 600, not 200.
Concept
The two tangent formulas differ in the sign between the radii. Adding them cancels the cross term 2r₁r₂, because (r₁ − r₂)² + (r₁ + r₂)² = 2r₁² + 2r₂².
That leaves L² + M² = 2d² − 2(r₁² + r₂²), which ties d to the sum of squares of the radii without knowing either radius.
Subtracting instead gives L² − M² = 4r₁r₂, which ties the tangents to the product of the radii.
The radii are never fixed, and they need not be. Here M² = 100 − 2r₁r₂, which cannot go negative because r₁² + r₂² ≥ 2r₁r₂, so the data hold for any radii whose squares add to 100.
Key facts
- L² + M² = 2d² − 2(r₁² + r₂²).
- L² − M² = 4r₁r₂.
- (a − b)² + (a + b)² = 2(a² + b²).
Study next
Common traps
- Dropping the radius terms and writing L² + M² = 2d², which leads to d = 10.
- Taking the square root of 2d² = 400 before dividing by 2, which leads to 20.
Both formulas are used one at a time in 25 Sep 2024, 09:00, Quant Q.9: radii 15 and 9 cm with centres 36 cm apart give 6√35 + 12√5 = 6√5(√7 + 2).
10 Sep 2024, 16:00, Quant Q.22 uses the transverse formula alone: √(17² − 15²) = 8 cm.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.