A and B contribute to a business investment in the ratio 3:5. They earn a profit of ₹64,000. A is a working partner and receives 10% of the profit extra. What is A’s total share?
- (a)₹26,500
- (b)₹28,000
- (c)₹38,500
- (d)₹36,000
Answer
Why
Correct — B. Take A's working-partner extra out first, then split the rest 3 : 5.
Extra to A = 10% of 64,000 = ₹6,400
Remaining profit = 64,000 − 6,400 = ₹57,600
A's capital share = 3⁄8 × 57,600 = ₹21,600
A's total = 21,600 + 6,400 = ₹28,000 → option (b)
Check: B gets 5⁄8 × 57,600 = ₹36,000, and 28,000 + 36,000 = 64,000.
Why the others are wrong
- (a)₹26,500 — ₹26,500 matches none of the working. A's plain 3⁄8 share of ₹64,000 is ₹24,000, and even adding 10% of that share gives ₹26,400, not ₹26,500.
- (c)₹38,500 — ₹38,500 is beyond even the most generous reading: 3⁄8 of the full ₹64,000 plus the whole ₹6,400 extra is ₹30,400. A holds just 3 of the 8 parts.
- (d)₹36,000 — ₹36,000 is B's share, 5⁄8 of the ₹57,600 left after A's extra. The question asks for A's total: ₹21,600 plus ₹6,400.
Concept
A working partner earns an extra for managing the business on top of the return on capital.
The working that reaches the key takes that extra out of the total profit first, divides the remainder in the capital ratio, and then adds the extra back to the working partner's share.
Here the extra is 10% of the whole profit, so it is ₹6,400.
The stem does not say whether the 10% comes out before the split.
Read instead as a bonus on top of a full 3⁄8 share, A would get 24,000 + 6,400 = ₹30,400, which is not among the options. The options and the key fit the off-the-top reading.
Key facts
- A working partner's extra comes out of the total profit before the capital split.
- 3⁄8 of ₹57,600 is ₹21,600, and 5⁄8 of it is ₹36,000.
- The shares must add back to the whole profit: 28,000 + 36,000 = 64,000.
Study next
Common traps
- Splitting the full ₹64,000 in 3 : 5 and then adding the ₹6,400, which pays the extra out of money already shared.
- Answering with ₹36,000, B's share, after doing the split correctly.
The same off-the-top structure appears at 21 Sep 2025, 16:00, Quant Q.7 (A takes 10% for managing and the remaining ₹90,000 is split by capital) and at 13 Sep 2025, 12:30, Quant Q.6 (A receives an extra 20% for management).
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.