Let x = √3 + √5 and y = √8 + √2. Which is greater?
- (a)x=y
- (b)x>y
- (c)x<y
- (d)Cannot be determined
Answer
Why
Correct — C. Both numbers are positive, so compare their squares.
x² = 3 + 5 + 2√(3 × 5) = 8 + 2√15
y² = 8 + 2 + 2√(8 × 2) = 10 + 2 × 4 = 18
Is 8 + 2√15 below 18? Subtract 8: is 2√15 < 10, i.e. √15 < 5?
Square both: 15 < 25, which is true.
So x² < y², hence x < y → option (c)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)x=y — Equality needs x² = 18, but x² = 8 + 2√15 ≈ 15.75. In decimals x ≈ 3.97 and y ≈ 4.24, so the two sums are not equal.
- (b)x>y — This reverses the inequality. x² ≈ 15.75 is below y² = 18, and for positive numbers the larger square belongs to the larger number, so y is greater.
- (d)Cannot be determined — x and y are fixed positive numbers, not variables, so they can always be compared. Squaring settles it: 8 + 2√15 against 18.
Concept
To compare sums of square roots without a calculator, square both sides. For positive numbers squaring keeps the order, so the larger square marks the larger number.
(√a + √b)² = a + b + 2√(ab), so each square becomes a whole number plus one root, and those are easy to compare.
Here y also simplifies directly: √8 = 2√2, so y = 2√2 + √2 = 3√2 = √18.
Decimals work too if you know √2 ≈ 1.414, √3 ≈ 1.732 and √5 ≈ 2.236: x ≈ 3.968 and y ≈ 4.243. Squaring is the safer route when two values are closer than your decimals are accurate.
Key facts
- (√a + √b)² = a + b + 2√(ab).
- For positive p and q, p < q exactly when p² < q².
- √8 + √2 = 2√2 + √2 = 3√2 = √18.
- √15 ≈ 3.873, so 8 + 2√15 ≈ 15.75.
Study next
Common traps
- Comparing term by term: √8 beats √5 but √3 beats √2, so that look settles nothing.
- Choosing 'Cannot be determined' because the terms point different ways, when any two fixed numbers can be compared.
Here the stem names the two sums x and y, and the options are the possible orderings plus 'Cannot be determined'.
Squaring also settles the surd-sum comparisons at 18 Sep 2025, 12:30, Quant Q.3 (√6 + √2 against √5 + √3) and 19 Sep 2025, 09:00, Quant Q.3 (√7 + √2 against √6 + √3).
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.