If P is the maternal uncle of Q, how is Q related to P’s sister?
- (a)Niece/Nephew
- (b)Cousin
- (c)Son
- (d)Cannot be determined
Answer
Why
Correct — A. Rule: a maternal uncle is the mother's brother.
P is Q's maternal uncle, so P is the brother of Q's mother.
The key reads P's sister as a sister of P other than Q's mother. She is then Q's mother's sister, Q's maternal aunt.
Q is the child of her sister, so Q is her niece or nephew. Q's gender is not given, so the relation is Niece/Nephew, option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)Cousin — A cousin is in Q's own generation, such as P's children. P's sister is one generation above Q, so Q cannot be her cousin.
- (c)Son — Son assumes Q is male, and the stem never states Q's gender. It also takes P's sister to be Q's own mother, while the key reads her as Q's aunt.
- (d)Cannot be determined — The key treats the relation as fixed: with P's sister read as Q's maternal aunt, Q is her niece or nephew. The note on this card sets out the other reading.
Concept
Maternal means on the mother's side. A maternal uncle is the mother's brother, and a maternal aunt is the mother's sister.
So P and Q's mother are siblings, and any sister of P is either Q's mother or Q's aunt.
To an aunt, her sister's child is a niece (a girl) or a nephew (a boy). The combined option covers both, because the stem does not say whether Q is male or female.
The stem does not say which of P's sisters is meant. Q's mother is herself P's sister, and on that reading Q is her son or daughter.
The key takes the aunt reading, and this card is written around it.
Key facts
- A maternal uncle is the mother's brother.
- A sister's child is a niece or a nephew.
- Q's mother is herself one of P's sisters.
Study next
Common traps
- Answering Son when the stem never states Q's gender.
- Choosing Cousin, which is Q's relation to P's children, not to P's sister.
A mother's sister also decides 24 Sep 2024, 09:00, Reasoning Q.11, where D, the sister of E's mother A, is keyed as E's 'Mother's sister'.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.