One pipe can fill a tank 6 times faster than another pipe. If both the pipes together can fill the tank in 40 minutes, then in how many minutes will the slower pipe alone be able to fill the tank?
- (a)290
- (b)275
- (c)285
- (d)280
Answer
Why
Correct — D. Let the slower pipe alone take T minutes, and add rates — never times.
Slower pipe = 1/T of the tank per minute
Faster pipe fills 6 times faster = 6/T per minute
Together = 1/T + 6/T = 7/T, and that equals 1/40
T = 7 × 40 = 280 minutes → option (d)
Check: 1/280 + 6/280 = 7/280 = 1/40
Why the others are wrong
- (a)290 — If the slower pipe took 290 minutes the pair would finish in 290/7 ≈ 41.4 minutes, not the 40 the question fixes.
- (b)275 — 275 gives 275/7 ≈ 39.3 minutes together — quicker than the stated 40, so this slower pipe is being made too fast.
- (c)285 — 285 gives 285/7 ≈ 40.7 minutes together. It is close, but 7/T = 1/40 has the single solution T = 280.
Concept
Pipe-and-cistern items are work items in disguise, and the one rule that carries them is that rates add, times do not. A pipe that fills a tank in T minutes works at 1/T of the tank a minute.
Watch the comparison in the stem. One pipe is 6 times faster, so its rate is 6/T and the pair fill at 7/T.
Setting 7/T against the given combined time of 40 minutes returns T in a single step, with no need to find the faster pipe's own time at all.
Read 6 times faster as a rate six times the slower pipe's. That is the reading the options support: taking it as 1 + 6 = 7 times would give 8⁄T = 1⁄40 and T = 320, which no option carries.
On the six-times reading the faster pipe alone takes 280⁄6 ≈ 46.7 minutes.
Key facts
- A pipe filling a tank in T minutes works at 1/T of the tank per minute.
- Pipes opened together add their rates: 1/T + 6/T = 7/T.
- 7/T = 1/40 gives T = 280 minutes for the slower pipe and about 46.7 minutes for the faster one.
Study next
Common traps
- Averaging the two times instead of adding the two rates
- Answering with the faster pipe's time of about 46.7 minutes when the stem asked for the slower one
The same comparison, worded as times as fast, is asked with other multipliers at 26 Sep 2024, 09:00, Quant Q.21 (four times as fast, together in 48 minutes) and 26 Sep 2024, 16:00, Quant Q.7 (twice as fast, together in 45 minutes).
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.