P and Q are two fixed points 10 cm apart, and R is a point on PQ such that PR = 6 cm. By what percentage is the length of QR decreased when the length of PR is increased by 5%?
- (a)7%
- (b)8.5%
- (c)7.5%
- (d)8%
Answer
Why
Correct — C. P and Q are fixed, so PQ stays 10 cm throughout and whatever PR gains, QR loses.
QR = 10 − 6 = 4 cm
PR after a 5% rise = 6 × 1.05 = 6.3 cm (5% is charged on PR's own 6 cm)
New QR = 10 − 6.3 = 3.7 cm
Decrease in QR = 4 − 3.7 = 0.3 cm
Percentage decrease = 0.3⁄4 × 100 = 7.5% → option (c)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)7% — 7% would mean QR fell by 0.28 cm. PR rises by 5% of its own 6 cm, which is 0.30 cm exactly, and every millimetre of it comes out of QR.
- (b)8.5% — No step here produces 8.5%. The fall is pinned at 0.3 cm and the original QR at 4 cm, so the only defensible ratio is 0.3⁄4.
- (d)8% — 8% is what 0.3⁄3.7 rounds to — dividing by the new QR instead of the original. Percentage change always sits on the starting value, 4 cm.
Concept
Two lengths that must add to a constant do not change by the same percentage.
PR + QR = PQ = 10 cm at every instant, so the absolute changes are equal and opposite: PR up 0.3 cm means QR down 0.3 cm.
The percentages differ because the bases differ. 0.3 on a base of 6 is 5%; the same 0.3 on a base of 4 is 7.5%.
The whole question is a test of which number you divide by, and the smaller a part is, the louder any given absolute change speaks in percentage terms.
R is described as a point on PQ, so PR and QR are the two pieces of a 10 cm segment — there is no third piece to absorb the change.
Key facts
- P and Q are fixed, so PR + QR = 10 cm at all times.
- A 5% rise on PR is 5% of 6 cm = 0.3 cm, not 5% of the 10 cm segment.
- Percentage decrease uses the original QR of 4 cm as its base, giving 0.3⁄4 = 7.5%.
Study next
Common traps
- Taking 5% of PQ (0.5 cm) rather than 5% of PR.
- Dividing the 0.3 cm fall by the new QR of 3.7 cm, which gives about 8.1%.
- Assuming QR falls by 5% because PR rose by 5%.
The numbers stay small enough to do in the head and the work hides in the base — the mark goes to whoever notices that the 5% is charged on PR while the answer is asked about QR.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.