In a certain code language, A + B means ‘A is the son of B’, A − B means ‘A is the wife of B’, A × B means ‘A is the brother of B’ and A ÷ B means ‘A is the mother of B’. Based on the above, if ‘P + Q ÷ R − T × M’, which of the following is true?
- (a)T is the brother of P.
- (b)M is the sister of T.
- (c)P is the brother of R.
- (d)Q is the mother of M.
Answer
Why
Correct — C. Rule: translate the string one operator at a time, left to right, before concluding anything.
P + Q means P is the son of Q.
Q ÷ R means Q is the mother of R.
R − T means R is the wife of T.
T × M means T is the brother of M.
So Q is mother to both P and R — to P by the first link, to R by the second. P is called a son, so P is male.
Two children of one mother, one of them male: P is the brother of R, option (c).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)T is the brother of P. — T is R's husband, since R is the wife of T. That makes T a brother-in-law to P, not a brother.
- (b)M is the sister of T. — T is the brother of M, which fixes T's gender and not M's. M may be male, so 'sister' is never established.
- (d)Q is the mother of M. — Q is mother to P and R only. M is reached through T, who married into the family, so no parent link runs from Q to M.
Concept
Symbol-coded relations are solved by translating the whole string first and reading the family off the translation.
Two habits save the mark. First, note the gender each symbol fixes: son, wife, brother and mother each fix one person, and options often turn on a gender that was never fixed at all.
Second, keep the direction straight. A ÷ B means A is the mother of B, never B the mother of A. Here the whole chain is not even needed — P and R both hang off Q, and that settles it.
The legend is defined afresh inside the question, so a symbol set carried over from another paper will mislead. At 12 Sep 2024, 12:30, Reasoning Q.8 the +, − and × carry exactly these meanings, but ÷ there means 'is the daughter of'.
Key facts
- In this question A ÷ B means A is the mother of B, and A − B means A is the wife of B.
- 'P is the son of Q' fixes P as male, while 'T is the brother of M' fixes T as male and leaves M open.
- P and R share the mother Q, which makes them siblings.
Study next
Common traps
- Assuming M is female because T is called a brother
- Reversing a link and reading A ÷ B as B being the mother of A
- Carrying a symbol legend over from another question instead of reading the printed one
The A + B stem also runs at 9 Sep 2024, 16:00, Reasoning Q.19 and at 12 Sep 2024, 12:30, Reasoning Q.8. Both print a legend that differs from this one, and both ask how one named person relates to another rather than which of four statements is true.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.