1.Supreme Court Seeks Periodic Law Reviews (Legislative Review Mechanism)
What & Where
Periodic review: SC suggests expert‐led scrutiny of every law at 20–50 yr intervals
Section 81, RPA 1951: election petition must reach jurisdictional High Court within 45 days of result
RPA 1951: core statute regulating delimitation, voter rolls, qualifications, election offences across India
Quick Facts for MCQs
Legal & Policy
- SupremeCourt: legislative audit needed to spot outdated, politically driven or conflicting provisions
- Example laws needing tweaks: IT Act 2000 for cybercrime; Bihar Prohibition Act causing bail surge
- Misuse concern: IPC 498A illustrates unintended consequence of protective provisions
Challenges
- Politicalwill: reviews can be stalled or skewed toward electoral gains e.g. Farm Laws 2020 debate
- Legalcomplexity: interlinked statutes risk anomalies like POCSO–IPC child pornography overlap
- Publicparticipation: low legal literacy exemplified by limited inputs to 2020 Criminal Law panel
International Examples
- UnitedKingdom: Law Commission repealed archaic Witchcraft Act 1735 after systematic review
- Australia: ALRC conducts scheduled thematic reports ensuring contemporary relevance
- USA: PATRIOT Act amended periodically to balance security with privacy rights
Reform Bodies
- Institutions: Administrative Reforms Commission, NCRWC 2000, Ranbir Singh Committee 2020, Law Commission
- LawCommission tasks: repeal deadwood, draft DPSP-linked bills, advise on judicial administration
Way Forward
- StrengthenLawCommission: give autonomy, funds, mandated cyclical review calendar
- UseTechnology: MyGov consultations; AI analytics for impact assessment and drafting efficiency
- ResourceAllocation: dedicated reform budget plus training for legislators, judges, enforcement cadres
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| Act involved | Representation of the People Act, 1951 |
| Section 81 limit | 45 days from result declaration |
| Petition forum | High Court of the constituency |
| RPA focus | Seats allocation, delimitation, electoral rolls, offences |
| First Law Commission (British era) | 1834; chaired by Lord Macaulay |
| First Law Commission (post-Independence) | 1955; M.C. Setalvad |
| Current Law Commission | 23rd; tenure 1 Sep 2024 – 31 Aug 2027 |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
In India, ‘judicial review’ implies
With reference to the Constitution of India, prohibitions or limitations or provisions contained in ordinary laws cannot act as prohibitions or limitations on the constitutional powers under Article 142. It could mean which one of the following?








