Select the correct active form of the given sentence. Why was such a letter written by your brother?
- (a)Why was your brother writing such a letter?
- (b)Why did your brother write such a letter?
- (c)Why does your brother write such a letter?
- (d)Why had your brother written such a letter?
Answer
Why
Correct — B. Read the tense off the passive first. Was written is was + past participle: the simple past passive.
In the active, the doer, your brother, becomes the subject, and a simple past question needs did + base verb: 'Why did your brother write such a letter?'
Why stays in front and 'such a letter' becomes the object → option (b).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)Why was your brother writing such a letter? — Was writing is past continuous, whose passive would be 'was being written'. Choosing it changes the tense.
- (c)Why does your brother write such a letter? — Does write is simple present, whose passive is 'is written'. The given sentence is in the past.
- (d)Why had your brother written such a letter? — Had written is past perfect, whose passive is 'had been written'. The given passive has neither had nor been.
Concept
A voice change keeps the tense and swaps the roles: the agent after by becomes the subject, and the passive subject becomes the object.
Match each passive to its active:
was written → wrote, or did write in a question
is written → writes, or does write
was being written → was writing
In a wh-question the question word stays first, and a simple past question takes the helper did.
Key facts
- Simple past passive: was or were + past participle (was written).
- A simple past active question uses did + base verb: Why did he write?
- Past continuous passive: was or were being + past participle (was being written).
- Past perfect passive: had been + past participle (had been written).
Study next
Common traps
- Choosing 'was writing' because it keeps the was of the passive — was writing is past continuous
- Choosing 'had written' because the letter was written earlier — the passive has no had, so the tense is simple past
The present-tense twin is 18 Sep 2024, 09:00, English Q.20: 'Why are you repeatedly called by her?' is keyed 'Why does she call you repeatedly?'.
19 Jan 2026, 11:00 AM, English Q.2 also asks for an active form, from a past continuous passive: 'was being painted' is keyed 'were painting'.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.