If 3x − ky + 8 = 0 and 9x − 18y + 20 = 0 have no solution, find k.
- (a)9
- (b)10
- (c)2
- (d)6
Answer
Why
Correct — D. Two lines have no solution when they are parallel but distinct: a₁⁄a₂ = b₁⁄b₂ ≠ c₁⁄c₂.
Ratio of the x-coefficients: 3⁄9 = 1⁄3
Ratio of the y-coefficients: (−k)⁄(−18) = k⁄18
Set them equal: k⁄18 = 1⁄3, so k = 18 ÷ 3 = 6
Check the constants: 8⁄20 = 2⁄5, which is not 1⁄3, so the lines never meet → option (d)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)9 — With k = 9 the y-ratio is 9⁄18 = 1⁄2, not the 1⁄3 of the x-ratio. The slopes differ, so the lines cross at exactly one point.
- (b)10 — k = 10 gives a y-ratio of 10⁄18 = 5⁄9 against the x-ratio 1⁄3. Unequal ratios mean one crossing point, a unique solution, the opposite of what is asked.
- (c)2 — k = 2 gives a y-ratio of 2⁄18 = 1⁄9, a third of the x-ratio 1⁄3. The lines are not parallel, so they still meet once.
Concept
Each equation ax + by + c = 0 is a straight line, and the ratios of the coefficients decide how two lines meet.
a₁⁄a₂ ≠ b₁⁄b₂: they cross once, a unique solution
a₁⁄a₂ = b₁⁄b₂ = c₁⁄c₂: they are the same line, infinitely many solutions
a₁⁄a₂ = b₁⁄b₂ ≠ c₁⁄c₂: they are parallel, no solution
Both y-terms carry a minus sign, so the signs cancel: (−k)⁄(−18) = k⁄18. Keep the signs whenever the equations mix them, because dropping one minus sign turns k = 6 into k = −6.
Key facts
- No solution: a₁⁄a₂ = b₁⁄b₂ ≠ c₁⁄c₂ (parallel, distinct lines).
- Infinitely many solutions: a₁⁄a₂ = b₁⁄b₂ = c₁⁄c₂ (the same line).
- Unique solution: a₁⁄a₂ ≠ b₁⁄b₂ (intersecting lines).
Study next
Common traps
- Stopping at a₁⁄a₂ = b₁⁄b₂ without checking the constants: if c₁⁄c₂ matched too, the lines would coincide.
- Inverting one ratio, writing 3⁄9 = 18⁄k, which gives k = 54.
Here the constants, 8 and 20, pass the 'not equal' check, so k is whatever matches the slopes.
The same condition decides 17 Sep 2024, 09:00, Quant Q.15 (k = 5 there), and 26 Sep 2024, 09:00, Quant Q.6 asks for the equation that makes a no-solution pair with 5x + 7y − 8 = 0.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.