A sentence is provided in direct speech. From the four given options, choose the one that most accurately conveys the sentence in its corresponding indirect speech. He said, “The sun rises in the east.”
- (a)He said that the sun rose in the east.
- (b)He said that the sun has risen in the east.
- (c)He said that the sun rises in the east.
- (d)He said that the sun had risen in the east.
Answer
Why
Correct — C. The trigger is the content: 'The sun rises in the east' is a universal truth, true whenever it is said.
After a past reporting verb like said, the tense normally moves one step back. A universal truth is the standard exception: its present simple stays.
So: He said that the sun rises in the east → option (c).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)He said that the sun rose in the east. — rose applies the ordinary backshift, rises → rose. The universal-truth exception keeps the present, because the sun still rises in the east now.
- (b)He said that the sun has risen in the east. — has risen is present perfect, which reports one completed rising, not a daily fact. It is not a backshift of rises either, since backshift moves the present to the past.
- (d)He said that the sun had risen in the east. — had risen moves the tense two steps back, present to past perfect, and turns a permanent fact into a single event before he spoke.
Concept
In reported speech, a past reporting verb (said, told) normally pulls the reported verb one tense back: 'I am tired' → he said that he was tired.
The exception is a universal truth, a statement that is always true. Its tense does not change: 'The earth moves round the sun' → the teacher said that the earth moves round the sun.
Check the content before you shift the tense.
Some grammars also accept the backshifted form for a fact that is still true. The key here applies the classic rule, which keeps a universal truth in the present.
Key facts
- After a past reporting verb, the present simple normally becomes past simple: 'I am busy' → he said that he was busy.
- A universal truth keeps its present tense: He said that the sun rises in the east.
- The reporting verb itself stays as said, with that introducing the reported clause.
Study next
Common traps
- Backshifting automatically because the reporting verb is said — check first whether the reported statement is always true.
- Choosing had risen because it sits furthest in the past — the present moves at most one step back, and here not at all.
The ordinary backshift, for contrast, is keyed at 12 Sep 2025, 16:00, English Q.22: 'I am not feeling well' becomes 'He said that he was not feeling well.'
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.