A conical bucket is cut at one-third its height from the top. What is the ratio of the volumes of the two parts (top part to bottom part)?
- (a)1 : 8
- (b)1 : 26
- (c)1 : 27
- (d)1 : 7
Answer
Why
Correct — B.
Cutting at a fixed height means a plane parallel to the base, so the top piece is a small cone similar to the whole.
Height ratio, top cone : whole = 1 : 3
Volume ratio = the cube of that = (1⁄3)³ = 1⁄27
Bottom piece (frustum) = 1 − 1⁄27 = 26⁄27 of the whole
Top : bottom = 1⁄27 : 26⁄27 = 1 : 26 → option (b).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)1 : 8 — 1 : 8 squares the scale factor instead of cubing it: (1⁄3)² = 1⁄9, then 1 : 8. That is the ratio of curved surface areas, not volumes.
- (c)1 : 27 — 1 : 27 compares the top cone with the whole cone. The question asks top part to bottom part, so take the top away: 27 − 1 = 26.
- (d)1 : 7 — 1 : 7 is the answer for a cut at half the height: (1⁄2)³ = 1⁄8 of the volume on top, leaving 7⁄8 below.
Concept
Similar solids scale by powers of the linear ratio k: lengths by k, areas by k², volumes by k³.
A plane parallel to a cone's base cuts off a smaller, similar cone. Here k = 1⁄3, so the top cone holds 1⁄27 of the volume and the frustum below holds the remaining 26⁄27.
The key reads the cone vertex up, so the top piece is the small cone. Read vertex down, the bottom piece would be the small cone (two-thirds of the height, 8⁄27 of the volume) and the ratio 19 : 8, which no option offers.
Key facts
- For similar solids with linear ratio k, volumes are in the ratio k³.
- Curved surface areas of similar solids are in the ratio k².
- A cut at one-third of a cone's height, measured from the vertex, leaves 1⁄27 of the volume in the small cone.
- A cut at half the height leaves 1⁄8 of the volume in the small cone and 7⁄8 in the frustum.
Study next
Common traps
- Squaring the height ratio, which gives an area ratio (1 : 8)
- Comparing the top piece with the whole cone (1 : 27) instead of with the frustum
18 Sep 2025, 12:30, Quant Q.13 runs the same cube law backwards: the top section is 1⁄8 of the volume, so the height ratio is ∛(1⁄8) = 1⁄2, keyed 1 : 2.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.