Change the following from active to passive: The agent could have sold the house.
- (a)The house could have been sold by the agent.
- (b)The house could be sold by the agent.
- (c)The house could have sold by the agent.
- (d)The house could had been sold by the agent.
Answer
Why
Correct — A. The verb is could have sold: a modal, then have + past participle.
To make it passive, keep the modal and have, add been, and keep the past participle:
could have sold → could have been sold
The object the house becomes the subject, and the doer moves into a by-phrase. The house could have been sold by the agent → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)The house could be sold by the agent. — could be sold is the passive of could sell, not of could have sold. Dropping have moves the possibility from the past into the present.
- (c)The house could have sold by the agent. — been is missing. A passive needs a form of be before the past participle, and could have sold leaves the active verb unchanged.
- (d)The house could had been sold by the agent. — could had breaks the modal rule. A modal is followed by the bare infinitive, so after could the form is have, never had.
Concept
The passive is be + past participle, and the form of be copies the tense of the active verb.
After a modal perfect, be takes the form been: modal + have been + past participle.
must have written → must have been written
should have told → should have been told
could have sold → could have been sold
Could have sold speaks of a past possibility, often one that did not happen: the agent could have sold the house, but did not. The passive keeps that meaning only because it keeps have.
Key facts
- Passive of a modal perfect: modal + have been + past participle.
- A modal is followed by the bare infinitive: could have, never could had.
- Could be sold is the passive of could sell.
- In the passive the active object becomes the subject, and the active subject moves into a by-phrase.
Study next
Common traps
- Choosing (c) because it keeps every word of the original verb, when the passive needs been
- Choosing (b) because it reads more simply, when dropping have changes the time
- Writing could had been by letting the past tense spill onto have
The same modal perfect is keyed at 19 Sep 2024, 16:00, English Q.18: Meenakshi could have sent a reply → A reply could have been sent by Meenakshi.
A plain modal is keyed at 15 Sep 2025, 16:00, English Q.12: may confer → may be conferred.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.