If P is the brother of Q, R is the sister of Q, and S is the father of P, how is R related to S?
- (a)Daughter
- (b)Niece
- (c)Wife
- (d)Sister
Answer
Why
Correct — A.
Rule: brothers and sisters share a father.
P is Q's brother and R is Q's sister, so P, Q and R are siblings.
S is P's father, so S is R's father too.
R is a sister, so R is female: R is S's daughter → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)Niece — Niece is the daughter of a brother or sister. That would make S R's uncle, but S is the father of R's brother P, so S is R's father.
- (c)Wife — Wife would put R in S's generation. R is a sibling of P, S's child, so R is one generation below S.
- (d)Sister — Sister would make R a sibling of S. R's sibling is P, and S is P's father, not his brother.
Concept
Place each person on a small family tree and read off the link asked for.
P, Q and R sit on one level as brothers and sisters. S sits one level above P as his father, and siblings share a father, so S is R's parent too. The word sister fixes R as female, which turns child into daughter.
Q's gender is never given: Q has a brother (P) and a sister (R), but nothing says whether Q is a son or a daughter. The answer does not need it.
Key facts
- Brothers and sisters share the same parents, so a parent of one is a parent of all.
- 'R is the sister of Q' tells you R is female, whatever Q is.
- A niece is a daughter of one's brother or sister, or of one's brother-in-law or sister-in-law.
Study next
Common traps
- Treating Q as male because P is 'the brother of Q': the sentence fixes P's gender, not Q's
- Reading 'S is the father of P' as a link to P alone, and missing that it makes S the father of R as well
21 Sep 2025, 16:00, Reasoning Q.12 turns on the same shared father: A is the father of B and B is the brother of C, keyed A as C's father.
19 Sep 2025, 09:00, Reasoning Q.22 chains siblings the same way (A brother of B, B sister of C, C father of D) and keys Uncle.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.