Consider the following statement and choose the option that follows. Problem: Frequent breakdown of ATM machines in remote areas. Course of: Action I. Banks should deploy mobile ATMs in these areas. Action II. Banks should shut down ATMs that face regular issues.
- (a)Only I follows
- (b)Only II follows
- (c)Both follows
- (d)Neither follows
Answer
Why
Correct — A.
Rule: a course of action follows if it is practical and reduces the stated problem.
The problem: people in remote areas lose cash access when ATMs break down.
Action I, mobile ATMs, brings cash service to those areas while fixed machines fail. It follows.
Action II, shutting the faulty ATMs, takes the service away. It does not follow.
Only I follows → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)Only II follows — Shutting down the faulty ATMs leaves remote areas with fewer machines, so the people the problem affects lose access. That makes the problem worse, not smaller.
- (c)Both follows — Both follows needs Action II too. Closing machines removes the service rather than restoring it, so II fails and Both fails with it.
- (d)Neither follows — Neither follows would mean mobile ATMs do not help. They carry cash service to the very areas where fixed machines keep failing, so I follows.
Concept
In course-of-action items, first restate the problem in plain words: here, remote areas keep losing ATM service. Then test each action with one question: does it reduce that problem in a practical way?
An action that removes the failing service and puts nothing in its place leaves the affected people worse off. Shutting ATMs is that kind of action. Mobile ATMs do the opposite.
Action II is not absurd in itself: a bank might retire an unreliable machine. It fails here because the statement offers no replacement, so closing machines in remote areas cuts access further.
Key facts
- A course of action should be practical and should reduce or solve the stated problem.
- An action that withdraws the very service the problem is about, with nothing in its place, does not follow.
- Judge each action on its own first, then match the pair to Only I, Only II, Both or Neither.
Study next
Common traps
- Choosing Both because shutting faulty machines sounds decisive
- Treating any action aimed at the faulty machines as a solution, even one that removes the service
The same opener and option wording, Only I / Only II / Both follows / Neither follows, asks about conclusions at 19 Sep 2025, 09:00, Reasoning Q.4 (organic vegetable subscriptions, keyed Only I).
18 Sep 2025, 12:30, Reasoning Q.4 uses the same opener for assumptions about cheaper long-distance train tickets (keyed 'Only I is implicit').
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.