A is three times more efficient as a worker than B, which allows A to complete a job in 60 days less than B. If they work together, they can finish the job in:
- (a)19.2 days
- (b)22.5 days
- (c)16 days
- (d)20 days
Answer
Why
Correct — B.
The key reads the stem as A doing 3 × B's work per day.
Time is inverse to efficiency: if A takes t days, B takes 3t.
Gap: 3t − t = 60, so t = 30. A takes 30 days, B takes 90.
Combined rate: 1⁄30 + 1⁄90 = 3⁄90 + 1⁄90 = 4⁄90 of the job per day
Together: 90 ÷ 4 = 22.5 days → option (b)
Why the others are wrong
- (a)19.2 days — 19.2 days fits neither reading of the ratio. Three times as efficient gives 22.5 days, and four times as efficient gives 16 days.
- (c)16 days — 16 days is what you get if "three times more" means four times as efficient: A 20 days, B 80 days, together 80 ÷ 5 = 16. The key does not take that reading.
- (d)20 days — 20 days is A's time alone under the four-times reading, not the pair's time. Under the keyed reading A alone needs 30 days and the two together 22.5.
Concept
For a fixed job, efficiency and time are inversely proportional. If A does 3 times B's daily work, A needs one-third of B's time, so the times are t and 3t.
The 60-day gap is the difference of those times, 2t = 60. Once each time is known, add the daily rates, never the days, and invert the total.
The wording is loose. Read literally, "three times more efficient" can mean four times as efficient, and that reading gives 16 days, also among the options. The key takes it as three times as efficient, and the card follows the key.
Key facts
- Efficiency ratio 3 : 1 means time ratio 1 : 3 for the same job.
- Two workers together: time = product ÷ sum of their times, 30 × 90 ÷ 120 = 22.5 days.
- Rates add, times do not: 1⁄30 + 1⁄90 = 4⁄90 of the job per day.
Study next
Common traps
- Giving the more efficient worker the longer time: efficiency 3 : 1 means time 1 : 3
- Averaging or adding the two times (30 and 90) instead of adding the daily rates
26 Sep 2024, 09:00, Quant Q.21 gives the ratio as speed: one pipe fills a tank four times as fast as the other, together they take 48 minutes, so the slower pipe alone takes 5 × 48 = 240 minutes.
26 Sep 2024, 16:00, Quant Q.7 does the same with a pipe twice as fast: together 45 minutes, so the slower pipe A alone takes 3 × 45 = 135 minutes.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.