Instruction: Identify the assumptions that must hold for the statement to be valid, then choose the correct option. Statement: Despite increasing consumer interest, electric vehicles are still significantly more expensive than gasoline-powered vehicles, and subsidies are essential to boost their adoption. Assumptions: I. The price difference is a major barrier to widespread adoption of electric vehicles. II. Subsidies can make electric vehicles affordable for consumers. III. The adoption of electric vehicles will significantly reduce carbon emissions.
- (a)Only I and II are implicit
- (b)Only II and III are implicit
- (c)All are implicit
- (d)Only I is implicit
Answer
Why
Correct — A.
Rule: an assumption is what the statement must take for granted to make sense.
I is implicit. Calling EVs more expensive and subsidies essential assumes the price gap is what holds adoption back.
II is implicit. Prescribing subsidies to boost adoption assumes subsidies can make EVs affordable.
III is not. The statement never says why adoption matters, so carbon emissions lie outside it.
I and II together → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)Only II and III are implicit — It drops I, which the statement leans on: subsidies are essential because price holds adoption back. And it adds III, which the statement never raises.
- (c)All are implicit — III is the extra. The statement argues about price and subsidies and gives no reason for wanting more EVs, so emissions are not assumed.
- (d)Only I is implicit — It misses II. Calling subsidies essential to boost adoption takes for granted that subsidies can bring EVs within reach of buyers.
Concept
An assumption is an unstated premise: take it away and the statement stops making sense. Test each one by negating it.
Not I: if price were no barrier, subsidies would not be essential.
Not II: if subsidies could not make EVs affordable, recommending them would be pointless.
Not III: if EVs did nothing for emissions, the statement would still stand, since it never mentions them.
III may well be true, but truth is not the test. An assumption must be needed by this statement, and this statement never mentions emissions.
Key facts
- An assumption is implicit only if the statement depends on it.
- Negation test: if denying it makes the statement pointless or false, it is implicit.
- A true but unrelated claim, such as III here, is not an assumption.
Study next
Common traps
- Marking III implicit because it sounds true, although the statement never mentions emissions
- Missing II because the statement says subsidies are essential, not that they work
12 Sep 2025, 16:00, Reasoning Q.6 uses the same instruction on an automation statement and also keys Only I and II, leaving out III, a claim that automation will replace human labor in all sectors.
14 Sep 2025, 12:30, Reasoning Q.5 does the same with job displacement from automation and AI, keyed Only I and II, where III claims the displacement is temporary.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.