Find the part of the sentence that contains an error: The policy aims to neither penalise first-time offenders (1)/ nor those who may have violated norms (2)/ due to systemic ambiguity (3)/ rather than deliberate intent. (4)
- (a)(1)
- (b)(2)
- (c)(3)
- (d)(4)
Answer
Why
Correct — A. Neither ... nor is a correlative pair. Whatever follows neither must be the same kind of phrase as whatever follows nor.
After nor comes a noun phrase: those who may have violated norms. After neither comes a verb: penalise first-time offenders. The two halves do not match.
Move neither to stand before the first noun phrase: "aims to penalise neither first-time offenders nor those who..." The fault is in part (1) → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)(2) — nor those who may have violated norms is the sound second half. Nor pairs with neither, and may have violated is a correct modal perfect for a possible past act. It sets the pattern part (1) must match.
- (c)(3) — due to systemic ambiguity gives the cause of the violation. Some older guides want owing to when the phrase modifies a verb, but due to meaning because of is widely accepted, and the key places the fault elsewhere.
- (d)(4) — rather than deliberate intent balances due to systemic ambiguity: ambiguity set against intent, noun phrase against noun phrase. The contrast is parallel and the sentence closes correctly.
Concept
Correlative conjunctions work in pairs: neither ... nor, either ... or, both ... and, not only ... but also. Each half must be followed by the same grammatical unit.
The repair is to move the first half, not to rewrite the sentence. Find what follows the second half, then put the first half directly before the matching unit.
Here nor is followed by a noun phrase, so neither must come after the verb both groups share: penalise neither X nor Y.
There is no 'No error' option here, so one of the four parts has to be wrong. Once the mismatch in part (1) is found, the rest need only a quick check.
Key facts
- Neither ... nor, either ... or, both ... and and not only ... but also are correlative conjunctions.
- The words after each half of a correlative pair must be the same kind of unit: noun phrase with noun phrase, verb with verb.
- Misplaced: She neither likes tea nor coffee. Correct: She likes neither tea nor coffee.
Study next
Common traps
- Accepting neither because it opens the pair, without checking what follows nor
- Marking part (3) on the old objection to due to, when part (1) holds a plain structural fault
The same placement rule decides 24 Sep 2024, 12:30, English Q.16, a not only ... but also item. The key moves not only to stand before by giving hints, so that it matches with providing her links after but also.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.