Change the following from active to passive: Why did the editor overlook the substantial stylistic anomalies?
- (a)Why have the substantial stylistic anomalies been overlooked by the editor?
- (b)Why are the substantial stylistic anomalies being overlooked by the editor?
- (c)Why did the substantial stylistic anomalies be overlooked by the editor?
- (d)Why were the substantial stylistic anomalies overlooked by the editor?
Answer
Why
Correct — D. The active verb is did overlook: did + base form, the simple past, set in a question.
The simple past passive is was/were + past participle. The new subject, the substantial stylistic anomalies, is plural, so were, and overlook becomes overlooked.
In a question, were moves in front of the subject, and the editor becomes by the editor: "Why were the substantial stylistic anomalies overlooked by the editor?" — option (d).
Why the others are wrong
- (a)Why have the substantial stylistic anomalies been overlooked by the editor? — have been overlooked is the present perfect passive. The active did overlook is simple past, so this option shifts the tense from past to present perfect.
- (b)Why are the substantial stylistic anomalies being overlooked by the editor? — are being overlooked is the present continuous passive. It moves a single, finished past action into the present and makes it ongoing.
- (c)Why did the substantial stylistic anomalies be overlooked by the editor? — did ... be overlooked is not English. In a be-passive the tense sits on be itself, so did drops out: Were they overlooked?, not Did they be overlooked?
Concept
Every passive is be + past participle, with be carrying the tense of the active verb.
Simple past: overlooked becomes was/were overlooked. Present perfect: has overlooked becomes has been overlooked. Present continuous: is overlooking becomes is being overlooked.
Because the tense sits on be, a passive question fronts was or were, not did: Did the editor overlook ...? becomes Were the anomalies overlooked ...?
Why stays at the front in both voices, and every option ends with by the editor, so the choice rests on the verb phrase alone.
Key facts
- Did + base form in a question marks the simple past: Why did the editor overlook ...?
- Simple past passive: was/were + past participle.
- The passive auxiliary agrees with the new subject: anomalies is plural, so were.
Study next
Common traps
- Keeping did in the passive, the mistake option (c) is built on
- Picking have been overlooked because it sounds natural after Why, without checking that it turns the simple past into present perfect
The same did-to-was/were conversion decides 25 Sep 2024, 12:30, English Q.11 (Why didn't she bring her son to my house? → Why wasn't her son brought by her to my house?).
It also decides 15 Sep 2025, 12:30, English Q.13 (Did the analysts anticipate ...? → Was the sudden market downturn anticipated by the analysts?).
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.