Madhav purchased an item for ₹42,000 and sold it at a loss of 20%. With that amount, he purchased another item and sold it at a gain of 30%. What is the overall gain (in ₹)?
- (a)6720
- (b)4200
- (c)2520
- (d)1680
Answer
Why
Correct — D. Follow the money through both sales.
First sale, a 20% loss on ₹42,000 returns 80% of it:
SP = 42,000 × 80⁄100 = ₹33,600
That entire ₹33,600 becomes the cost of the second item, sold at a 30% gain:
SP = 33,600 × 130⁄100 = ₹43,680
Overall gain = 43,680 − 42,000 = ₹1,680 → option (d)
One-line check: the money is multiplied by 0.8 and then by 1.3, and 0.8 × 1.3 = 1.04 — a net 4% gain, and 4% of ₹42,000 is ₹1,680.
Why the others are wrong
- (a)6720 — ₹6,720 is 16% of ₹42,000, but the two stages multiply to 0.8 × 1.3 = 1.04 — a net gain of exactly 4%, and no reading of the chain produces 16%.
- (b)4200 — The additive trap: −20% and +30% treated as +10%, and 10% of ₹42,000 is ₹4,200. Percentages taken on different bases never add — the 30% is earned on ₹33,600, not on ₹42,000.
- (c)2520 — ₹2,520 is 6% of ₹42,000, but the net effect of the two stages is 4%, which on ₹42,000 is ₹1,680.
Concept
Successive percentage changes multiply; they never add. A loss of x% is a factor of (1 − x⁄100) and a gain of y% is a factor of (1 + y⁄100).
So the whole two-stage story is a single product: 42,000 × 0.8 × 1.3 = ₹43,680. Order does not matter, since multiplication commutes — a 30% gain followed by a 20% loss lands on the same ₹43,680.
The net change is (0.8 × 1.3 − 1) × 100 = 4%, which is also what the shortcut x + y + xy⁄100 gives: −20 + 30 + (−20 × 30)⁄100 = 4.
The phrase 'with that amount' is what pins the second cost price at ₹33,600.
Had the question said he bought another item for ₹42,000, the answer would be different. That clause is doing real work and is worth re-reading before you compute.
Key facts
- Successive changes of x% and y% combine into a single change of x + y + xy⁄100 per cent.
- A 20% loss followed by a 30% gain is a net 4% gain, because 0.8 × 1.3 = 1.04.
- Selling at a 20% loss returns 80% of cost, so ₹42,000 becomes ₹33,600.
Study next
Common traps
- Adding −20 and +30 to get a 10% gain, which lands on option (b).
- Computing the 30% gain on the original ₹42,000 instead of on the ₹33,600 actually reinvested.
- Answering the second item's own gain of ₹10,080 rather than the overall gain on the original outlay.
SSC states a two-stage buy-and-sell chain and asks for the overall gain, sometimes stretching it to three stages or putting a discount in place of the loss.
The wording that decides the answer is always whether the full sale proceeds carry into the next purchase.
The same multiply-the-factors idea drives Quant Q.16 of this paper, where a 26% mark-up meets a 32% discount.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.