The income of a person is ₹16,500, and his expenditure is ₹12,000. Next year, his income increases by 24% but his expenditure decreases by 10%. The percentage increase (rounded off to the nearest integer) in his savings is:
- (a)115%
- (b)120%
- (c)95%
- (d)90%
Answer
Why
Correct — A.
Present savings = 16,500 − 12,000 = ₹4,500
New income = 16,500 × 1.24 = ₹20,460
New expenditure = 12,000 × 0.90 = ₹10,800
New savings = 20,460 − 10,800 = ₹9,660
Increase in savings = 9,660 − 4,500 = ₹5,160
Percentage rise = 5,160 ⁄ 4,500 × 100 = 114.67%
To the nearest integer, 115% → option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)120% — 120% would mean new savings of ₹9,900 (4,500 × 2.2). The actual figures are ₹20,460 against ₹10,800, so savings are ₹9,660 and the rise is 114.67%.
- (c)95% — 95% would need savings of ₹8,775, which no step here produces. The rise is measured on the old savings of ₹4,500: 5,160 ⁄ 4,500 = 114.67%.
- (d)90% — This is what forgetting the expenditure cut gives. Income alone at ₹20,460 against an unchanged ₹12,000 leaves ₹8,460 and an 88% rise; the 10% cut takes expenditure to ₹10,800.
Concept
Savings are a residual — income minus expenditure — so a percentage change in savings is never the difference of the two percentage changes. Income and expenditure start from different bases.
Here the 24% rise is worth 0.24 × 16,500 = ₹3,960 and the 10% cut is worth 0.10 × 12,000 = ₹1,200. Both add to savings, and 3,960 + 1,200 = ₹5,160, exactly the increase.
The final division is against the old savings of ₹4,500, not against income, not against the new savings.
The question says rounded off to the nearest integer, so 114.67% is meant to be reported as 115%.
Key facts
- Savings = income − expenditure, so a change in savings absorbs both moves at once.
- A percentage rise is measured on the original value, here the old savings of ₹4,500.
- 24% of ₹16,500 is ₹3,960 and 10% of ₹12,000 is ₹1,200, and together they are the ₹5,160 rise.
Study next
Common traps
- Subtracting the percentages, 24% − 10%, as though the two shared a base.
- Dividing the increase by the new savings of ₹9,660 instead of the old ₹4,500.
- Subtracting the ₹1,200 fall in expenditure when it actually adds to savings.
The same two levers, an income rise and an expenditure move, come back with different numbers.
25 Sep 2024, 16:00, Quant Q.7 has income ₹18,600 and expenditure ₹12,400 rising by 15% and 8%; 13 Sep 2024, 16:00, Quant Q.11 gives expenditure as 80% of income and raises the two by 15% and 5%.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.