Three of the following numbers are alike in a certain way and one is different. Pick the odd one out. (NOTE : Operations should be performed on the whole numbers, without breaking down the numbers into its constituent digits. E.g. 13 – Operations on 13 such as adding /deleting /multiplying etc., to 13 can be performed. Breaking down 13 into 1 and 3 and then performing mathematical operations on 1 and 3 is not allowed.) weerbb
- (a)11 – 363
- (b)15 – 450
- (c)13 – 507
- (d)9 – 243
Answer
Why
Correct — B. Rule: the second number is 3 × (the first number)².
11 → 3 × 11² = 3 × 121 = 363 ✓
13 → 3 × 13² = 3 × 169 = 507 ✓
9 → 3 × 9² = 3 × 81 = 243 ✓
15 → 3 × 15² = 3 × 225 = 675, but the paper prints 450
Three pairs obey the rule and 15 – 450 does not, so option (b) is the odd one out.
450 is 2 × 15², so the pair is built on the same skeleton with a multiplier of 2 where the others use 3.
Why the others are wrong
- (a)11 – 363 — 11 – 363 fits the rule: 11² = 121 and 121 × 3 = 363. It belongs to the group, so it is not the exception the question is after.
- (c)13 – 507 — 13 – 507 fits: 13² = 169 and 169 × 3 = 507. Its larger second number makes it look unlike the others, but the arithmetic is the same.
- (d)9 – 243 — 9 – 243 fits: 9² = 81 and 81 × 3 = 243. The small first number is the only thing setting it apart, and size is not the rule.
Concept
The NOTE printed with this item is the instruction that matters: operate on the whole number, never on its digits. Without it, a pair like 11 – 363 invites digit games that never generalise to the other three.
The whole-number rules in this family are usually a short formula in the first number — square it, cube it, multiply it, add a constant. Test the shortest formulas first, and test them on the pair with the smallest numbers.
Here 9 – 243 is the cheapest test. 243 ÷ 9 = 27, which is 3 × 9, so the second number is three times the square. Confirm on 11 and 13, then check 15 and the exception falls out.
What breaks is the multiplier, not the square. 450 = 2 × 15², so the odd pair still uses the first number squared and simply scales it by 2.
Key facts
- Three pairs satisfy second = 3 × first², giving 363, 507 and 243.
- 15 under the same rule would give 675, not the 450 the paper prints.
- 450 equals 2 × 15², so its multiplier is 2 rather than 3.
Study next
Common traps
- Operating on the digits of 363 or 450 despite the NOTE that forbids it.
- Stopping once two pairs agree and assuming the third one checked is the exception.
- Treating divisibility by the first number as the rule, since 450 and 675 are both multiples of 15.
The NOTE is printed word for word on this family in other shifts and only the formula moves. 9 Sep 2024, 16:00, Reasoning Q.4 keys 33 – 72 out of a set running second = first × 7/3, and 11 Sep 2024, 12:30, Reasoning Q.25 keys 45 – 70 out of a set running second = first × 8/5.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.