Select the option that expresses the given sentence in active voice. Were the plants being grafted by the gardener?
- (a)Was the gardener grafting the plants?
- (b)Were the gardener grafting the plants?
- (c)Was the gardener grafted the plants?
- (d)Were the plants grafting the gardener?
Answer
Why
Correct — A. The given sentence is a question in the past continuous passive: were + being + grafted.
Turned active, the agent 'the gardener' becomes the subject, and the verb drops to plain past continuous: was grafting.
'The gardener' is singular, so the auxiliary is was, not 'were', and the question keeps its inverted order: Was the gardener grafting the plants? That is option (a).
Why the others are wrong
- (b)Were the gardener grafting the plants? — Were does not agree with the singular subject 'the gardener'. The 'were' in the original belonged to 'the plants', which is plural, and agreement is redecided once the subject changes.
- (c)Was the gardener grafted the plants? — 'Was the gardener grafted' puts a past participle after 'was', which makes the clause passive again — and a passive verb here cannot then take 'the plants' as an object.
- (d)Were the plants grafting the gardener? — This swaps the roles and makes the plants the ones doing the grafting. A voice change must preserve who did what to whom; only the arrangement may move.
Concept
Voice change is mechanical once you name the tense. In a passive the tense lives in the auxiliary and the main verb is always the past participle.
Past continuous passive: was/were + being + V3, as in 'The plants were being grafted'.
Past continuous active: was/were + V-ing, as in 'The gardener was grafting the plants'.
Agreement then follows the new subject, not the old one, and that is where the mark is usually lost.
SSC keeps the sentence a question in both directions, so two things must survive the change: the voice and the question form. Convert it to a statement in your head, then re-invert the auxiliary to the front.
Key facts
- Past continuous passive is was/were + being + past participle.
- Its active counterpart is was/were + present participle, with the by-agent as subject.
- In a passive-to-active change the auxiliary agrees with the new subject, here singular.
- A past participle after 'was' keeps the clause passive, so it cannot take a direct object.
Study next
Common traps
- Carrying 'were' across from the original, because the eye reads the old auxiliary first.
- Leaving the past participle in place and producing 'Was the gardener grafted the plants'.
- Reversing agent and object under time pressure, which still reads fluently and means the opposite.
Both directions are set. Active from a continuous passive at 11 Sep 2024, 16:00, English Q.15 ('The letter was being typed by the secretary when the phone rang') and at 19 Sep 2024, 09:00, English Q.12 ('Data is being collected by the researcher').
The wh-question form is at English Q.2 here: 'By whom were you injured?' takes 'Who injured you?'
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.