Naman bought few apples for ₹720 from a shop. He negotiated the price and the shopkeeper reduced it by ₹2 per apple. Due to this Naman could buy four more apples than what he had bought earlier. How many apples did he originally buy?
- (a)36
- (b)44
- (c)40
- (d)48
Answer
Why
Correct — A. Let n be the number of apples he first bought. The spend is fixed at ₹720, so the price per apple is 720⁄n before and 720⁄(n + 4) after.
The price fell by ₹2:
720⁄n − 720⁄(n + 4) = 2
720(n + 4 − n) = 2n(n + 4)
2880 = 2n² + 8n
n² + 4n − 1440 = 0
(n + 40)(n − 36) = 0, and a negative count is impossible, so n = 36 → option (a).
Check: 720⁄36 = ₹20 and 720⁄40 = ₹18, a fall of exactly ₹2.
Why the others are wrong
- (b)44 — 44 does not give a ₹2 fall. 720⁄44 is about ₹16.36 and 720⁄48 is ₹15, a drop of roughly ₹1.36. The stem fixes the drop at ₹2 exactly.
- (c)40 — 40 is the number he ended up with, not the number he started with. 720⁄40 = ₹18 is the reduced price, and the question asks how many he originally bought.
- (d)48 — 48 makes the apples too cheap to move ₹2. 720⁄48 = ₹15 and 720⁄52 is about ₹13.85, a fall near ₹1.15. The larger n gets, the smaller the possible drop.
Concept
This is the fixed-budget family: total spend stays the same while price per unit and quantity move in opposite directions.
Write price as total ÷ quantity and the condition becomes a difference of two reciprocals, 720⁄n − 720⁄(n + 4) = 2. Clearing the denominators always produces a quadratic.
The numbers are picked so that the quadratic factorises. Here n² + 4n − 1440 splits as (n + 40)(n − 36), and the negative root is thrown away because a count cannot be negative.
Back-solving from the options is faster than the algebra if you check the right thing: divide 720 by the option and by option + 4, and keep the pair that differs by exactly ₹2.
Key facts
- With spend fixed at ₹720, the price per apple is 720⁄n, so a price change is a difference of reciprocals.
- n² + 4n − 1440 = 0 factorises as (n + 40)(n − 36).
- Originally: 36 apples at ₹20 each, costing ₹720.
- After the ₹2 cut: 40 apples at ₹18 each, still ₹720.
Study next
Common traps
- Solving for the new count and answering 40, which is the value after the reduction.
- Writing the difference the other way round as 720⁄(n + 4) − 720⁄n = 2, which has no positive root.
- Testing options by price alone without checking that the gap is exactly ₹2.
The story changes and the algebra does not: spend fixed, price per unit changed, quantity moved. Read the stem to see which of the two counts is being asked for.
A neighbouring variant sits at 19 Sep 2024, 09:00, Quant Q.1, where a vendor cuts ₹10 per kg to ₹7.2 per kg and also weighs 900 g as a kilogram, so both the price and the unit shift at once.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.