Parts of the following sentence have been given as options. Select the option that contains an error. No other place in this country is so better as Gulmarg, Kashmir.
- (a)No other place
- (b)in this country is
- (c)so better as
- (d)Gulmarg, Kashmir
Answer
Why
Correct — C. The faulty segment is so better as, which welds two different comparison frames together.
The frame so ... as takes the positive degree: 'is so good as Gulmarg'. The comparative better takes than: 'is better than Gulmarg'.
Either repair reads naturally, but the sentence as printed uses neither. Segment (c) is where the sentence breaks.
Why the others are wrong
- (a)No other place — No other place is a sound subject. 'No other' plus a singular noun is the standard way English states a superlative idea as a comparison, and it needs no repair.
- (b)in this country is — The verb is agrees with the singular 'place', and 'in this country' is an ordinary prepositional phrase narrowing it. Nothing in this segment is wrong.
- (d)Gulmarg, Kashmir — Gulmarg, Kashmir is only the thing being compared against, a place name with its region after a comma. The fault lies in the words that introduce it.
Concept
English compares in three degrees, and each degree has a fixed partner word.
The positive degree pairs with as ... as or so ... as — 'as good as', 'not so good as'. The comparative pairs with than — 'better than'. The superlative pairs with the — 'the best'.
Error-spotting items plant a mixed frame far more often than a rare word: a comparative inside an equality frame, as here, or 'more better', or 'than' after a plain adjective.
Find the degree word first, then check whether its partner is the right one.
The sentence means what a superlative would mean — that Gulmarg is the best — but states it as a comparison, which is why both repairs sound equally natural.
Key facts
- So ... as and as ... as take the positive degree, so 'so good as', never 'so better as'.
- A comparative adjective takes than: better than, larger than, more useful than.
- 'No other place is better than X' is the comparative way of saying X is the best.
Study next
Common traps
- Reading 'so better as' at speed and hearing the idiomatic 'so much better'.
- Suspecting the place name in segment (d) because it carries a comma.
Error-spotting is packaged in more than one way. This shift's English Q.3 splits a sentence into four printed segments and keys 'where we should visit several famous'; here the segments are the options themselves. The packaging changes, the task does not: find the part that breaks.
Related PYQs
No directly related past PYQ was found.