1.Constitutional morality contours debate (Constitutional Morality)
What & Where
Concept: ethical compass guiding exercise of public power within Constitution
Scope: Indian democracy, all three organs, citizens’ civic conduct
Rooted in: 1846 coinage by George Grote; enriched by Ambedkar’s writings
Quick Facts for MCQs
Evolution
- Dharma tradition: Tirukkural’s Aram linked virtue with governance
- 1846 Grote: coined term as reverence for constitutional forms
- Ambedkar: warned democracy mere top-dressing without cultivated morality
Judicial Practice
- SupremeCourt: concept cited in Manoj Narula, Sabarimala, Navtej Johar judgments
- Interpretation: judges weigh ethical intent alongside text, ensuring fairness and restraint
- Warning: excessive moral reading risks separation-of-powers breach
Challenges & Remedies
- Majoritarianism: popular morality threatens minority rights and dissent
- Bureaucracy: partisan loyalty dilutes rule-of-law culture
- Remedies: constitutional literacy, ethics panels, participatory democracy recommended
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| Coinage Year & Author | George Grote, 1846 |
| Key Indian Proponent | B. R. Ambedkar |
| Core Principles | Rule of law, institutional propriety, dissent, accountability |
| Landmark SC Invocations | Manoj Narula 2014; Sabarimala 2018; Navtej Johar 2018 |
| Main Threat Spotlighted | Majoritarian populism |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
Which one of the following statements is NOT correct?








