1.Judicial Dissent Significance (Judiciary)
What & Where
Judicial dissent – separate opinion disagreeing with majority, offering alternate constitutional reading.
Key forms – Intellectual, Political, Social dissents reflecting logic, anti-political stance, or socio-cultural divergence.
Main arenas – Supreme Court of India & U.S. Supreme Court as apex constitutional forums.
Quick Facts for MCQs
Legal & Policy
- Rights safeguard: Dissents defend liberty, equality, constitutional morality from transient majorities.
- Reform trigger: Highlight statutory or constitutional gaps prompting legislative correction.
- Independence marker: Regular dissent signals judiciary free from executive-legislative pressure.
Comparative Aspect
- Ideology divide: U.S. dissents often echo liberal-conservative alignment of appointing President.
- India focus: Dissents lean on text, societal context rather than party labels.
- Philosophy clash: U.S. originalist vs progressive; India embraces living-constitution morality.
Recent Cases
- SitaSoren 2023: Struck parliamentary privilege shield, strengthening anti-corruption regime.
- LaltaVaish 2024: Asserted industrial alcohol outside State tax ambit unless potable.
- Hijab 2022: Emphasised personal choice and pluralism within State schools.
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| India: appointment mode | Collegium; minimal overt political role |
| USA: appointment mode | President nominates, Senate confirms |
| ADM Jabalpur 1976 dissent | Justice H.R. Khanna upheld Article 21 during Emergency |
| Shayara Bano 2017 dissent | Justices Khehar & Nazeer backed triple talaq validity |
| Lalta Prasad Vaish 2024 dissent | Justice B.V. Nagarathna on States lacking power to tax industrial alcohol |
| Hijab split-verdict 2022 | Justice Dhulia stressed diversity over uniform secularism |
| Sita Soren 2023 ruling | Bribe-for-vote immunity (1998) overruled; corruption no longer privileged |
| Core impact of dissents | Catalyse amendments, enrich jurisprudence, display judicial independence |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
निम्नलिखित कथनों पर विचार कीजिए :





