Which of the following statements are correct regarding the International Monetary Fund (IMF) ? 1. India is a founder member of the IMF. 2. India's quota in the IMF is more than 4 percent. 3. Finance Minister is represented ex-officio on the IMF. 4. IMF conducts regular review of India's economic status under Article IV. Select the correct answer using the codes given below :
- (a)1, 2 and 3 only
- (b)1, 3 and 4 only
- (c)2 and 4 only
- (d)1, 2, 3 and 4
Answer
Why
Correct — B, (b) 1, 3 and 4 only.
Three of the four statements are correct and one is a number that is far too large. Take them in order.
STATEMENT 1 — 'India is a founder member of the IMF.' CORRECT. India joined the International Monetary Fund on 27 December 1945, the day the Articles of Agreement entered into force, and is therefore among its original members. India had taken part in the United Nations Monetary and Financial Conference at Bretton Woods in July 1944, at which the Fund and the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development were designed.
STATEMENT 2 — 'India's quota in the IMF is more than 4 percent.' INCORRECT, and this is the statement that decides the whole question. India's quota is SDR 13,114·4 million and its share of total voting power is about 2·63 per cent — substantial, placing India among the larger members, but nowhere near 4 per cent. The figure has risen over time, most recently through the quota reform agreed in 2010, and it has never approached the level the statement asserts.
STATEMENT 3 — 'Finance Minister is represented ex-officio on the IMF.' CORRECT. Every member country appoints a Governor to the IMF's Board of Governors, its highest decision-making organ. For India the Finance Minister serves as the ex-officio Governor, with the Governor of the Reserve Bank of India acting as the Alternate Governor. The Board of Governors meets ordinarily once a year, at the Annual Meetings, and delegates most of its powers to the Executive Board, which conducts the Fund's daily business.
STATEMENT 4 — 'IMF conducts regular review of India's economic status under Article IV.' CORRECT. Article IV of the Articles of Agreement is the provision under which the Fund exercises surveillance over its members' economic and exchange-rate policies, and the bilateral consultation it requires is known universally as the ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION. A Fund team visits the country, examines its economic and financial developments, discusses policy with the authorities, and the Executive Board then considers a staff report on it. India, like every other member, is subject to these consultations, which are held as a regular cycle.
So statements 1, 3 and 4 stand and statement 2 falls, which is option (b).
There is a shortcut worth seeing. Statement 2 appears in options (a), (c) AND (d) — that is, in every wrong option — and in none of the right one. A candidate who is confident that India's quota is well under 4 per cent has answered the question without adjudicating anything else. Counting which statement appears in the most options is a cheap first move on any coded list, and here it identifies the pivot immediately.
Statement 2 spells out 'percent' as a word rather than using the sign, unlike the percentages elsewhere on this paper; 'ex-officio' is hyphenated and set in roman; and 'Article IV' uses a roman numeral. All are as printed.
Why the others are wrong
- (a)1, 2 and 3 only — This accepts the inflated quota figure and rejects the Article IV consultation, which is the one Fund activity that touches every member every year without exception. Surveillance under Article IV is not a facility a country opts into, nor something reserved for members that borrow; it is an obligation of membership and applies to the largest economies in the world just as it does to the smallest. Rejecting statement 4 usually reflects an impression that the IMF only becomes involved with a country when that country is in difficulty, which is a misreading of what the institution does.
- (c)2 and 4 only — This keeps the one false statement, keeps one true one, and rejects the two that are most easily verified — India's founder membership and the Finance Minister's position as ex-officio Governor. India's presence at Bretton Woods in 1944 and its joining on 27 December 1945 are matters of record, and the appointment of a Governor to the Board of Governors is a requirement of membership that every country satisfies. An option that denies both while asserting an overstated quota share has the country's relationship with the Fund almost entirely wrong.
- (d)1, 2, 3 and 4 — Three of these four statements are correct, which is why this option is the most attractive of the three wrong ones: everything except the quota figure survives scrutiny. The quota figure does not. India's share of voting power is about 2·63 per cent, and its quota is SDR 13,114·4 million — a large share among 190-odd members, but not more than 4 per cent of the total. Where a list is correct except for a single number, the number is usually where the question is, and a candidate who cannot recall the exact figure should still be able to place it in the right order of magnitude relative to the largest members.
Concept
THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND was designed at the United Nations Monetary and Financial Conference at Bretton Woods in July 1944, together with the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development — the two are called the Bretton Woods twins. The Fund came into existence when the Articles of Agreement entered into force on 27 December 1945, and India was among the countries that joined that day. Its headquarters are in Washington.
THE QUOTA is the central concept of the institution and is worth understanding rather than memorising. Each member is assigned a quota, denominated in SPECIAL DRAWING RIGHTS, the Fund's unit of account. The quota does four things at once: it fixes the member's SUBSCRIPTION, the capital it must pay in; it fixes its VOTING POWER, through basic votes plus votes proportional to quota; it fixes its ACCESS to Fund financing, expressed as multiples of quota; it fixes its SHARE of general allocations of Special Drawing Rights. Quotas are reviewed periodically in General Reviews, and because voting power follows quota, quota reform is the principal arena in which the balance of influence between advanced and emerging economies is contested. India's quota is SDR 13,114·4 million and its voting share about 2·63 per cent.
GOVERNANCE. The BOARD OF GOVERNORS, with one Governor and one Alternate for each member, is the highest decision-making body and meets ordinarily once a year; India's Governor is the Finance Minister and the Alternate is the Governor of the Reserve Bank. The EXECUTIVE BOARD, sitting continuously in Washington, conducts daily business. The MANAGING DIRECTOR heads the staff and chairs the Executive Board.
WHAT THE FUND DOES falls into three parts. SURVEILLANCE — monitoring the economic and financial policies of members and of the world economy. Bilateral surveillance takes the form of the Article IV consultation; multilateral surveillance produces the flagship reports, including the World Economic Outlook and the Global Financial Stability Report. LENDING — providing financing to members facing balance-of-payments difficulties, under arrangements that normally carry policy conditions. CAPACITY DEVELOPMENT — technical assistance and training in areas such as tax administration, statistics and central banking.
The distinction between the Fund and the World Bank is the one most often tested: the Fund deals with macroeconomic stability, exchange rates and short-term balance-of-payments financing, while the Bank finances long-term development projects and programmes.
International economic institutions are a small but dependable strand on papers of this kind, and the IMF is the institution most often used, because its structure supplies several separable facts — founding, membership, quotas, governance, surveillance — that can be combined into a statement list.
This item is built around one numerical claim placed among three institutional ones. That is a common and effective construction: institutional facts can be reasoned about from general knowledge of how such bodies work, whereas a quota percentage cannot, so the number is where the difficulty is concentrated. The defence is to carry an order of magnitude even where the exact figure is not remembered — knowing that India's share is between 2 and 3 per cent, and that only the very largest economies reach the middle single digits, is enough.
The option structure reinforces the point. The false statement is present in all three wrong options, so the item reduces entirely to it. A candidate who tallies the statements across the options before adjudicating them will see at once where to spend the effort, and this paper's coded statement lists reward that habit repeatedly.
For an officer of a social-security organisation the Article IV consultation is more than a piece of institutional trivia. Its staff reports and the Fund's flagship publications are among the standard sources on the Indian macroeconomy, and the fiscal and financial-sector chapters of such reports bear directly on the environment in which a large public fund is invested.
Key facts
- India joined the International Monetary Fund on 27 December 1945 as a founding member, having taken part in the Bretton Woods Conference of July 1944.
- India's quota is SDR 13,114·4 million and its share of total voting power is about 2·63 per cent — well below 4 per cent.
- A member's quota determines its subscription, its voting power, its access to Fund financing and its share of Special Drawing Rights allocations.
- The Finance Minister of India is the ex-officio Governor on the IMF's Board of Governors, with the Governor of the Reserve Bank of India as Alternate Governor.
- Article IV of the Articles of Agreement is the basis of the Fund's surveillance; the bilateral Article IV consultation is an obligation of membership, not a facility for borrowers.
- The Fund's three functions are surveillance, lending for balance-of-payments difficulties, and capacity development.
- The IMF and the IBRD, designed together at Bretton Woods, are known as the Bretton Woods twins; both are headquartered in Washington.
- The Fund deals with macroeconomic stability and short-term balance-of-payments financing; the World Bank finances long-term development.
Study next
Common traps
- Overstating India's quota share. It is about 2·63 per cent of voting power, not more than 4 per cent.
- Thinking Article IV consultations apply only to countries that borrow from the Fund. Surveillance is an obligation of membership for every member.
- Confusing the Governor on the Board of Governors with the Executive Director. India's Governor is the Finance Minister; the Reserve Bank Governor is the Alternate.
- Failing to tally which statement appears in which option. Here the false statement is in all three wrong options, so it decides the item on its own.
Items on international economic institutions are set as three- or four-statement coded lists mixing institutional facts with one number. The institutional statements can usually be judged from an understanding of how such bodies are organised; the number cannot, so it is where the examiner concentrates the difficulty. Carry the founding dates, the headquarters, the governing organs, the flagship publications and an order of magnitude for India's position in each body. Expect the IMF, the World Bank, the World Trade Organization, the International Labour Organization and the Asian Development Bank, and expect at least one item that turns on distinguishing two of them from each other.
Related PYQs
EPFO_APFC_2016_Q26Which of the following is one of the Millennium Development Goals fixed by the UNO ?
- (a) Halving extreme poverty and halting the spread of HIV/AIDS
- (b) Develop a new variety of foodgrains which can ensure bumper crops
- (c) To ensure that population does not increase in the least developed countries
- (d) Develop procedures towards adequate and timely forewarning on hurricanes and tsunamis
Answer(a) Halving extreme poverty and halting the spread of HIV/AIDS
The Millennium Development Goals item — the other question on this paper about an international body's programme, and one testing the same kind of institutional recall.
EPFO_APFC_2016_Q49Whenever countries set up a Free Trade Area, they abolish all restrictions on trade among themselves and
- (a) They establish a common external tariff on imports from outside countries
- (b) They abolish all restrictions on imports from outside countries
- (c) They abolish all restrictions on imports from other Free Trade Areas
- (d) Each country maintains its own set of tariffs and quotas on imports from outside countries
Answer(a) They establish a common external tariff on imports from outside countries
The item on free trade areas, whose legal frame is the other pillar of the post-war international economic order that Bretton Woods began.
Practice
- practice — not a real PYQ
The Article IV consultation conducted by the International Monetary Fund is best described as
- (a)a condition attached to a Fund loan
- (b)a regular bilateral surveillance exercise applying to every member country
- (c)a review conducted only for countries with a balance-of-payments crisis
- (d)an audit of a member's foreign exchange reserves
Answer(b) a regular bilateral surveillance exercise applying to every member country — Article IV of the Articles of Agreement is the basis of Fund surveillance, and the consultation it requires is an obligation of membership rather than a condition on borrowing. A Fund team visits, discusses policy with the authorities, and the Executive Board considers a staff report.
- practice — not a real PYQ
A member country's quota in the International Monetary Fund determines all of the following EXCEPT
- (a)its subscription to the Fund
- (b)its voting power
- (c)its access to Fund financing
- (d)the exchange rate at which its currency is valued
Answer(d) the exchange rate at which its currency is valued — a member's exchange rate arrangement is its own choice, subject to the obligations in Article IV, and is not fixed by its quota. The quota does determine subscription, voting power, access to financing and the share in allocations of Special Drawing Rights.