1.Institutionalising Animal Representation in Law (Animal Welfare)
What & Where
Institutional Animal Representation — idea of fiduciary bodies legally voicing animal interests within Indian governance
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1960 — central law prescribing minimal fines for cruelty across India
Key judicial reference — SC ruling Animal Welfare Board vs A Nagaraja 2014 recognising animal personhood
Quick Facts for MCQs
Legal & Policy
- Contradiction — SC affirms dignity yet statutory law still classifies animals as replaceable property
- Vacancy — AWBI, SAWBs, SPCAs lack autonomy, budgets, enforcement authority
- Proposal — amend PCA Act, hike penalties, embed sentience definition
Institutional Gaps
- Conflict — AWBI reports to husbandry-promotion ministry creating policy capture risk
- Paper boards — many State Boards, District SPCAs exist only on paper; negligible funding
- Absence — no standing parliamentary committee dedicated to animal welfare
Sectoral Harm
- Farming — 70–80 % layer hens confined in battery cages despite Law Commission push to ban
- Infrastructure — highways, rails ignore wildlife corridors causing 1500+ human, numerous animal deaths 2019–22
- Transport — livestock routinely overcrowded; enforcement near-zero due to token fines
Proposed Reforms
- Guardians — constitutionally protected, multi-disciplinary animal trustees with fixed terms
- Animal-Impact Assessment — mandatory in clearances for roads, rails, mining, urban projects
- Public outreach — national coexistence campaigns enabling citizens to report violations
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| PCA Act Sec 11 fine | ₹10–₹50 (unchanged since 1960) |
| Livestock population | 535.78 million (20th Livestock Census) |
| IPC sections treating animals as property | 428 & 429 |
| Elephant deaths electrocution/train (2018–21) | 330 |
| Constitutional duty | Art 51A(g) “compassion to all living creatures” |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
वन्यजीव (सुरक्षा) अधिनियम, 1972 के अनुसार, किसी व्यक्ति द्वारा, यदि द्वारा किए गए वन्यजीव अपराध के अभियुक्त होने के विचार में, निम्नलिखित में से कौन-सा/से प्राणी का शिकार नहीं किया जा सकता?
With reference to Indian laws about wildlife protection, consider the following statements:






