1.Tribunal Reforms Act Verdict (Tribunal Reforms Act)

What & Where
Tribunal Reforms Act 2021: Centre-enacted statute abolishing/reshaping several appellate tribunals across India.
Supreme Court Judgment 2025: Bench invalidated key clauses for violating separation of powers & prior MBA IV-V rulings.
National Tribunal Commission: Court-mandated independent body for appointments, tenure, oversight—deadline four months.
Quick Facts for MCQs
Legal & Policy
- Principle: Parliament cannot re-enact provisions already struck down without curing defects.
- Court restored 5-yr minimum tenure, 10-yr advocate eligibility, balanced committee composition.
- Executive rule-making on pay/conditions declared contrary to tribunal autonomy.
Judicial Independence
- Short 4-yr terms linked to re-appointment risk seen as government leverage on adjudicators.
- Two-name panel option diluted primacy of judicial members in final selection.
- Civil-service salary parity viewed as undermining parity with High Court judges.
Administrative Impact
- Abolition shifted pending appeals to overburdened High Courts, risking delay, lost technical expertise.
- Centralised control projected as efficient but criticised for excessive ministerial discretion.
- Commission envisaged to unify recruitment, evaluation, infrastructure, budget independent of litigant ministries.
Pros & Cons Debate
- Supporters: uniformity, speedy appointments, experienced (>50 yrs) adjudicators, performance review via fixed terms.
- Critics: excludes younger talent, replicates struck-down clauses, executive dominance when Union is top litigant.
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| Enactment date | 13 Aug 2021 |
| Parent Ordinance | Tribunal Reforms Ordinance 2021 |
| Chairperson term (Act) | 4 yrs or 70 yrs age whichever earlier |
| Member term (Act) | 4 yrs or 67 yrs age whichever earlier |
| Minimum entry age fixed | 50 years |
| Selection body head | CJI or nominee (Search-cum-Selection Committee) |
| Tribunals abolished | IPAB, Film Certification AT, Airport AT, etc. |
| Articles cited by Court | 14, 323A, 323B + basic structure |
| Compliance directive | Form National Tribunal Commission in 4 months |
| Earlier safeguards revived | Madras Bar Association IV & V norms |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
प्रतिषेध रिट उच्चतम न्यायालय या उच्च न्यायालयों द्वारा किसे और किस प्रयोजन से जारी किया गया एक आदेश है ?
Which of the following conditions is/are necessary for the issue of a writ of certiorari in India?









