1.Custodial Deaths Highlight Need for Police Reforms (Police Reforms)
What & Where
Definition Custodial death means death in police, judicial or military custody pre-trial, during trial or post-conviction
Coverage Includes natural causes like illness and unnatural causes like torture, assault or negligence
Hotspot Tamil Nadu leads south; 490 deaths 2016-22, Sivaganga case drew Madras HC ire
Quick Facts for MCQs
Legal & Policy
- Absence Standalone anti-torture law despite 273rd Law Commission draft 2017
- Status India signed but not ratified UN Convention Against Torture limiting global accountability
- Judgments DK Basu 1996, Nilabati Behera 1993, PUCL 2005 mandated arrest memo, compensation, CCTV respectively
Accountability & Oversight
- Opaque Investigations evidence destruction, shifted post-mortems, missing CCTV in Ajith Sivaganga case
- Disciplinary-Gap Only 0.23 % NHRC cases saw police punishment; convictions almost nil nationwide
- Internal Control weak; arrests sans FIR, unofficial detention, rank-and-file cover-ups prevalent
Social Concerns
- Marginalisation SCs over-represented in preventive detention; reflects structural bias in policing
- Health Risk overcrowded understaffed prisons foster suicide, untreated illness, mental distress deaths
- Public Perception Madras HC termed recent torture “more brutal than murder”, flagging constitutional disregard
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| NHRC judicial-custody deaths 2021-22 | 2,150 |
| NHRC police-custody deaths 2021-22 | 155 |
| NHRC disciplinary action rate | 0.23 % (21 cases) |
| NCRB deaths 2000-2020 | 1,888 |
| NCRB police convictions 2000-2020 | 26 |
| Judicial inquiries 2017-22 | 345 |
| Convictions 2017-22 | 0 |
| Tamil Nadu deaths 2016-22 | 490 |
| SCs share preventive detenues TN | 38.5 % |
| TN SC population share | 20 % |
| Key judgment DK Basu year | 1996 |
| UNCAT status India | Signed, not ratified |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
The Judgment of the Supreme Court in Peoples’ Union for Civil Liberties v. Union of India 2004 is related to which of the following ?







