1.Supreme Court on Begging (Right to Dignity)
What & Where
Definition – SC says state-run beggars’ homes are constitutional trusts, not quasi-penal or charity shelters.
Process – Admission, care, rehabilitation must respect Article 21 dignity; children routed via Juvenile Justice Act 2015.
Geography – Begging regulated by states/UTs; most adopt Bombay Prevention of Begging Act 1959.
Quick Facts for MCQs
Legal & Policy
- Competence – No central anti-begging statute; states free to frame or adopt 1959 Bombay Act.
- Delhi HC & SC view – Criminalising poverty violates dignity; socio-economic solutions preferred.
- BNS 2023 – Trafficking sections usable to crush organised begging rings.
Judicial Directives
- Safety – Separate women/child units, counselling, education; kids shifted to child-care institutions, not beggars’ homes.
- Health – 24-hour medical screening; dieticians to monitor nutrition.
- Infrastructure – Biennial third-party audits, strict occupancy caps, mandatory vocational training.
Scheme & Statistics
- SMILE components – medical aid, skill training, shelter linkage, 2026 “beggar-free” target.
- Funding – Central grants routed via District Social Welfare officers; NGOs act as implementing partners.
- Monitoring – Dashboard tracks admissions, rehabilitation, recidivism rates.
Social Concerns
- Drivers – poverty, disability, disasters, caste stigma, organised trafficking.
- Impacts – public health hazards, tourist discomfort, strain on urban services.
- Rights – Arbitrary arrests under anti-begging laws termed human-rights violations by courts.
Key Data Points
| Feature | Data-Point |
|---|---|
| Landmark case | M.S. Patter v. State of NCT Delhi (2025) |
| Constitutional article invoked | Article 21 – right to life with dignity |
| List entry for vagrancy laws | Concurrent List, Entry 15 |
| Dominant state law | Bombay Prevention of Begging Act 1959 |
| Delhi HC 2018 ruling | Harsh Mander v. Union of India decriminalised begging |
| National scheme | SMILE – launched 2022 |
| Persons rehabilitated under SMILE | 970 (352 children) till 2024 |
| Census 2011 beggar count | 4,13,670 nationwide |
| State with most beggars | West Bengal |
| Child protection treaty cited | UN Convention on the Rights of the Child |
Related UPSC Prelims PYQs
S1. In many countries, there are millions of people who are underprivileged and deprived







